Constructive Criticism Welcomed

[neeld]

Backs: Goddard, Deledio, Lake, M.Clarke, Docherty, Ellis, Bugg (Sierakowski, L.Brown)

Midfielders: Pendlebury, Ablett, Swan, Murphy, J.Selwood, Ziebell (Shiel, McDonald)

Rucks: Mumford, Sandilands (Giles, Witts)

Forwards: Martin, Robinson, Dangerfield, Christensen, Zorko, Hampton, Kennedy (Smedts, Treloar)

[nathan11]

think you need to take some cash out of the mids and spend it on your forwards don't think any of robinson danger christensen will score anywhere enough to make your team competitive

[PICCOLLO]

Bit heavy in the mids there Neeld.  Rookie mids provide the best source of capital for upgrading your team.  Playing 3 rookie backs on the park is risky, esp. given you're starting Docherty who is recovering from hip surgery.  Similar story with your fwds there.  Ditch Murphy and Pendlebury, spread the cash to your other lines and work your way from there.

[Ringo]

Def: Lake and Docherty concerns
Mids; Super strong but are they too strong
Rucks; No issues
Forwards: Real risk here expecting all of your playing forwards to turn in big scores. Really need a super prem in here for team balance.

Would ditch 2 of your mids and replace with rookies who will make you cash and strengthen forward and defence lines with prem.

Rating 5/10 due to weaknesses in forward line and suspect defence.

[neeld]

How about this:

Goddard
Deledio
Lake
Hargrave
Dempsey
Howard
Clarke

Ellis
Bugg

Ablett
Swan
Montagna
Shuey
McDonald
Gibson

Morabito
Reid

Mumford
Smith

Giles
Stepehenson

Franklin
Martin
Robinson
Dangerfield
Christensen
Winderlich
Porplyzia

Saad
Weedon

[4INAROW]

alot of risks in that team, but surely u know that. it's a better balanced side.

maybe try get 1 more premium at d3.

personally id downgrade winderlich to a good rookie and upgrade either hargrave or lake with the cash.

even though i don't agree with the structure, it will be pretty balanced out then.