PLEASE RATE ME :)

[JamesT13]

BACKS:B.Goddard B.Delidio H.Shaw D.Heppell R.Hargrave M.Clarke B.Ellis SUB: B.Smedts S.Morris

MIDS: G.Ablett M.Murphy J.Selwood M.Barlow D.Zorko D.Shiel SUB: L.Brown J.McDonald

RUCKS: A.Sandialnds H.McIntosh SUB: J.Giles O.Stephensen

FORWARDS: L.Franklin P.Chapman D.Martin A.Christensen J.Brown J.Porplyzia A.Saad SUB: T.Walsh S.Rowe

5.3k left

There are a couple players who I'm still not sure on and I have a feeling it needs to be a little stronger still. A few ideas will be much apreciated. i'll rate your team back.

[Obese Arachnid]

My opinion would be ditch Hargrave & get a GWS rookie or any rookie really.

Mids look good.

Rucks, personal choice but i'm not a fan of H Mac, many are.

Fwds: I'ld only take two max of Christ. Brown & Porps. too much risk for mine.
Downgrade one to a rookie GWS (Hampton or Treloar NAB dependent) & upgrade one to a Prem. Pav?

[JamesT13]

My opinion would be ditch Hargrave & get a GWS rookie or any rookie really.

Mids look good.

Rucks, personal choice but i'm not a fan of H Mac, many are.

Fwds: I'ld only take two max of Christ. Brown & Porps. too much risk for mine.
Downgrade one to a rookie GWS (Hampton or Treloar NAB dependent) & upgrade one to a Prem. Pav?

Thanks for the feedback mate. I never was sure on Hargrave but might see how he goes in the nab cup before I rule him out completely. I am a fan of hmac so I might keep him. I might downgrade props to a rookie but I like brown and Christensen so where would I put my money?

[Obese Arachnid]

If you are determined to take the Brown Dog, Christensen, Hargrave & H Mac, then you'll only have about $100k after downgrading Porps, so that makes it tough.

Upgrade Barlow or Heppell but i'm guessing you won't like either of those two suggestions.

[JamesT13]

If you are determined to take the Brown Dog, Christensen, Hargrave & H Mac, then you'll only have about $100k after downgrading Porps, so that makes it tough.

Upgrade Barlow or Heppell but i'm guessing you won't like either of those two suggestions.

Say I were to downgrade Hargrave and props and keep christensen and brown. Who would I upgrade?

[Obese Arachnid]

I think it's really up to you now as i'm no expert & it comes down to personal choice.

ME i'd still upgrade one of the ones i've already mentioned, H Mac, Christ.,Brown , Barlow or Heppell.
Probably Hmac if you don't want to screw with what you've got.

Seems like your pretty set on what you want so maybe just wait for NAB as that will probably change all permutations & combinations anyway.