Rate my team? First Draft

[ElectricMayhem]

My first year playing SC, so I'm probably doing this completly wrong.
I could use some opinions on my team.

[ando_10]

its okay mate

menzel will miss most the year with that knee injury

no to duigan this year to expensive and hes scores will be average

interesting choice with lower hopefully he can be a valuable player for you

i cringe whenever i see jolly in a side hes no good i know a ton of people who had him last year and were NOT happy ha.

jon patton coming back from surgery to will be lucky to play round 1 wont be a big scorer imo.

6.5/10

[ElectricMayhem]

its okay mate

no to duigan this year to expensive and hes scores will be average

Any idea on who I could swap him for?

[Hippo]

Duigin ninjured
Patton ninjured
Rowe ninjured
Menzel ninjured

Lower over Barlow!!? Really!!!

feedback is research every player you want to put in your team

[upthemaidens]

first comment was "its ok mate"   ummmmmmm   no it isnt, its a train wreck.
without going through everything thats wrong with it, i would just start again.  hippo is correct  do some research

[ando_10]

its okay mate

menzel will miss most the year with that knee injury

no to duigan this year to expensive and hes scores will be average

interesting choice with lower hopefully he can be a valuable player for you

i cringe whenever i see jolly in a side hes no good i know a ton of people who had him last year and were NOT happy ha.

jon patton coming back from surgery to will be lucky to play round 1 wont be a big scorer imo.

6.5/10

swap menzel for christensen?

swap jolly for hmac/kreuzer?

swap duigan for grimes?

and lower for barlow

maybe porps for patton if you have the money

[ando_10]

first comment was "its ok mate"   ummmmmmm   no it isnt, its a train wreck.
without going through everything thats wrong with it, i would just start again.  hippo is correct  do some research

i clearly picked out what was wrong with it the rest is fine.

[upthemaidens]

first comment was "its ok mate"   ummmmmmm   no it isnt, its a train wreck.
without going through everything thats wrong with it, i would just start again.  hippo is correct  do some research

i clearly picked out what was wrong with it the rest is fine.

u think darling is a good pick?  daisy thomas really?  and to go with the other 5 or so that u pointed out,, given that rookie selections dont matter at this point, that means maybe half the selections were good..  i think that can be considered a start over

[ando_10]

first comment was "its ok mate"   ummmmmmm   no it isnt, its a train wreck.
without going through everything thats wrong with it, i would just start again.  hippo is correct  do some research

i clearly picked out what was wrong with it the rest is fine.

u think darling is a good pick?  daisy thomas really?  and to go with the other 5 or so that u pointed out,, given that rookie selections dont matter at this point, that means maybe half the selections were good..  i think that can be considered a start over

yeah im not saying your wrong bud i agree but im saying ive seen alot worse on here and why not thomas? could be a real good pick up.. alot of these teams on here are the same im not going to tell him to get rid of a player who has potential to dominate this year and then tell him to go with someone heaps of people already have... yes its touch and go with darling but i think he could do well. only thing i could say about darling is not to have him as 4th forward alot of better options

[upthemaidens]

first comment was "its ok mate"   ummmmmmm   no it isnt, its a train wreck.
without going through everything thats wrong with it, i would just start again.  hippo is correct  do some research

i clearly picked out what was wrong with it the rest is fine.

u think darling is a good pick?  daisy thomas really?  and to go with the other 5 or so that u pointed out,, given that rookie selections dont matter at this point, that means maybe half the selections were good..  i think that can be considered a start over

yeah im not saying your wrong bud i agree but im saying ive seen alot worse on here and why not thomas? could be a real good pick up.. alot of these teams on here are the same im not going to tell him to get rid of a player who has potential to dominate this year and then tell him to go with someone heaps of people already have... yes its touch and go with darling but i think he could do well. only thing i could say about darling is not to have him as 4th forward alot of better options

ok cool, look im all for being unique, but be unique when its logical and doesnt weaken your team. 
he could get priddis,boyd,thompson etc. all just as unique as thomas  and got to be better options