JMac v Kav

[coolfugitiv0]

Who would you pick?
I want both, but can't have both without sacrificing a premium.
My other rookies are pretty much locked (T.Mitchell, D.Shiel, and Kerridge for DPP)

[nathan11]

i would have to say Jmac dont think kav will get regular games early on with a fully fit bombers midfield

[cortez]

I dont think either wil get  regular games. Macdonald cause he will only play between 12-15 games for the year and kav wont be in the bombers best 22.

[Bosh]

Hampton from GWS?

[Manbearpig]

I dont think either wil get  regular games. Macdonald cause he will only play between 12-15 games for the year and kav wont be in the bombers best 22.

Well, 12-15 games would be more than enough. I suspect he'll play more games than Kav.

[Talisman]

Oh my god, you'll be missing out on the no.1 mid rookie by the looks of things: S. Clifton! Mature age GWS mid, who killed it last year when they were playing in the NEAFL - his combo with Giles will be "Legen - wait for it - dary!"

Bugger Kerridge & Kav, I'd go JMac & Clifton instead... Both will play, not sure I can say the same for Kerridge & Kavanagh. And remember, never choose a player just for their DPP status if you believe there is another better player for a comparable price.

[Colliwobblers]

Oh my god, you'll be missing out on the no.1 mid rookie by the looks of things: S. Clifton! Mature age GWS mid, who killed it last year when they were playing in the NEAFL - his combo with Giles will be "Legen - wait for it - dary!"

Bugger Kerridge & Kav, I'd go JMac & Clifton instead... Both will play, not sure I can say the same for Kerridge & Kavanagh. And remember, never choose a player just for their DPP status if you believe there is another better player for a comparable price.

+1 finity i'd be having a look at zorko (if not in your fwd) and hampton/treloar/miles from GWS also just saying :)