Freaking backs!!

[Haddy1.0]

I have shaw at the moment but not convinced yet. Thought maybe one of the other 2 might be a smarter pick.
All votes and comments are appreciated and any other thoughts on who to get are welcomed. Cheers

[Peter]

I think Shaw is an upgrade target; Heppell for me

[Jalapeno]

Good cheaper alternatives are broughton, duffield and suban... Freo backs should scire better under lyon in my opinion. Just not too sure whichs one to pick out of them haha.

[stew42]

Good cheaper alternatives are broughton, duffield and suban... Freo backs should scire better under lyon in my opinion. Just not too sure whichs one to pick out of them haha.

Mate, one of the things he was looking for was consistency!!!

[Big_Cox14]

Grimes!

[The Silent Partner]

Good cheaper alternatives are broughton, duffield and suban... Freo backs should scire better under lyon in my opinion. Just not too sure whichs one to pick out of them haha.

Mate, one of the things he was looking for was consistency!!!

I like that one Heppell for me he will just cruise along at a 95 av this year
Shaw could go higher but as mentioned perhaps upgrade target
Enright will put along at around 85 avg

[stew42]

Good cheaper alternatives are broughton, duffield and suban... Freo backs should scire better under lyon in my opinion. Just not too sure whichs one to pick out of them haha.

Mate, one of the things he was looking for was consistency!!!

I like that one Heppell for me he will just cruise along at a 95 av this year
Shaw could go higher but as mentioned perhaps upgrade target
Enright will put along at around 85 avg

That's a fairly big drop for Enright and a fairly big rise for Hep D? Is that just a gut feeling???

[The Silent Partner]

More speculation I guess Heppell had a good first year and I see him only improving on that whereas Enright although very consistent i see him tapering off a tad he avg 91 last year i only see him going down to 85 . They both in my book will be consistent just see heppell  bringing it up and turning into one of the most important players for the dons.
Who will take over Lingys role?

[stew42]

More speculation I guess Heppell had a good first year and I see him only improving on that whereas Enright although very consistent i see him tapering off a tad he avg 91 last year i only see him going down to 85 . They both in my book will be consistent just see heppell  bringing it up and turning into one of the most important players for the dons.
Who will take over Lingys role?

Fair point, I like that as I have just pencilled in Hep over Enright :)
I don't think Ling's role will be replaced (specialist tagger/DT antichrist). Another running, possession hogging mid would be nice :)

[Haddy1.0]

I've thrown in Heppell but now just tossing up between birchall and grimes.
Any thoughts on those 2?

[stew42]

I've thrown in Heppell but now just tossing up between birchall and grimes.
Any thoughts on those 2?

Birch for consistency, Grimes if you desperately need the cash

[Colliwobblers]

i voted enright for consistant high scoring, but my team and my gut says heppell may be a little less consistant but may overall average higher and have some big tons along the way.

[Juddster5]

I have shaw at the moment but not convinced yet. Thought maybe one of the other 2 might be a smarter pick.
All votes and comments are appreciated and any other thoughts on who to get are welcomed. Cheers

Haddy1.0 Whats the rest of your backline? Would be easier to give advice mate.

[chatters24]

I think Shaw is your best bet. May not be the most consistent, if you want consistency then go Rutten, if you want the highest overall scorer then I would think Shaw. Take the good with the bad.

[Haddy1.0]

backline at the moment is
Goddard, Lids, Birchall, Heppell, Clarke, Ellis, Smedts (Mohr, Talia)
Backline is the weakest line of my whole team as im sure it is with most people so any help to fix it up is appreciated, cheers.