A Brown Porpoise windowlicker!

[The Silent Partner]

In my initial team I have all three I see them all making money Brown will perhaps be the keeper but if they produce a good quick return the porpoise and the windowlicker will be upgraded. Brown and porpoise both have rd 11 bye and with the gws reserves it does make it too many on the bye but will have them upgraded bye then hopefully what do you think?

[Mozza3]

Of those 3 I think Windowlicker has a few question marks on him. Although he's cheap i can't really see you getting an awful lot of value out of him.

[ShaynoB]

Nup. Downgrade Porp & if u have a lil bit of money either upgrade 1 of Brown or Winder

Having all 3 is way to much of a risk imo

[The Silent Partner]

Of those 3 I think Windowlicker has a few question marks on him. Although he's cheap i can't really see you getting an awful lot of value out of him.

Yes the query is there but Hird seems to regard him

Nup. Downgrade Porp & if u have a lil bit of money either upgrade 1 of Brown or Winder

Having all 3 is way to much of a risk imo

Tis very risky but if fit all will guaranteed to play  in comparison to some forward rooks which will drop in and out of sides only after the Nab cup will there be better indication. I agree tis huge gamble  but I can see 80+ averages at the least from all three whereas the rooks unless we hit a good one may only bring ave of 50-60 ok there will be a premium to lift those scores but here is fwd structure
FWD: D. Martin, L. Franklin, J. Brown, J. Winderlich, D. Beams, A. Tomlinson, J. Porplyzia (A. Treloar, T. Couch)