Ruck Problems

Started by hibbo, March 03, 2009, 03:12:46 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

hibbo

not sure which combo to go with:

Cox, White (Currie, Pyke) + $246,900
vs
Hille, Sandilands (Currie, Pyke)

i figure that hille and sandi will give me on average 190 points per game where as Cox and one of the swans boys will give me around 160. So naturally i am leaning towards the hille/sandi combo, but that extra 250K would be very handy.

Just can't decide
thoughts??
cheers

bjrouse

If you can make up the remaining 30 points than go with the lower
I doubt you will
Other problem you face is leaving Cox out He is awesome.
Why not try Cox and MacIntosh

hibbo

#2
@ bjrouse
for now i have gone cox and white as i do think i can make up the 30 points in other areas- ive fitted ablett into my team (not relying on his price to drop) and strengthened my backline.
thanks for thoughts thou...


diddley

you dont think you will have a problem employing 3 different rucks from the one team in yours. one will get a game, the next will only get a game if the first is out, then the rookie will prob never get a game. what happens if/when cox's ankle/foot flares up again?

postmanpat

My solution is to go Petrie and Hille for my rucks. I spent a fair bit but they will score close to 100 every week.

Fatty

I've done the same Thing Pat. The second ruck options this year don't look all that appealing. There's no Troy Simmonds type of stand out that there was last season. I don't trust Luenberger.

Fatty.

cooney17


Alex7089

Quote from: cooney17 on March 05, 2009, 04:24:04 AM
Cox and Simmonds
NO. Simmonds? He was only worth it last year because of the cheapness

cooney17

My rucks are cox hille currie and white.


Charman?

Hawks_1976

Rucks need to be locked in and forgotten about for the year IMO.

Cox/Hille/White/rookie.

Now worry about the rest of your squad.

XabiJay

rucks this year wont fall or increase alot and i think you get what ya pay for so im just buying and leaving them for the year. if i can make some money off the 1st yearers ill be lucky i think