Please rate my side

[tompat515151]

Hi guys,Tis is a rough first draft of my team. All advice is appreciated.

I am trying to go either rookies and premiums throughout but still have a couple of mid range players.

Def - Goddard,H.Shaw,Deledio,Broughton,Marty Clarke,Buntine,B Ellis   Bench - Smedts, B Morris

Mid - Ablett,Swan,Pendlebury,Murph,Atley,James Macdonald    Bench - Tom Mitchell,S Ross

Ruck - Kreuzer, Macintosh       Bench - Longer, O Stephensen

FWD - Franklin,Power,Martin,Dangerfield,Porplyzia, Dick, S Rowe     Bench - Kerridge,Zorko

[Luigi197]

Having both Clarke and Shaw is risky, but your decision.
I dont rate Atley much at all. Jump on Shiel instead.
A lot of money is used up there in the mids; Barlow or Ward wouldn't go half bad.

rate your team: 8.5/10
Good effort, but watch NAB cup :)