CRITICISM PLEASE!!

[jayknows]

here's JayKnows first team for 2012..

Backline: B Goddard, B Deledio, G Broughton, J Grimes, M Clarke, B Ellis, B Smedts (T Mohr, L Brown)

Midfielders: D Swan, G Ablett, J Watson, M Barlow, L Hayes, D Shiel (D Tyson, T Mitchell)

Rucks: A Sandilands, H McIntosh (J Giles, O Stephensen)

Forwards: L Franklin, M Robinson, D Martin, C Rioli, J Brown, J Winderlich, A Saad (D Zorko, A Treloar)

CASH LEFT: $11,800


Might Swap:
J Watson > J Selwood 
G Broughton > D Heppell
C Rioli > S Sidebottom

ofcourse rookies will change depending on NAB cup performances
i'm also feeling weak in my lack of any DPP in my midfield, ill have to make some changes there


what are your thoughts?? rate out of 10?

[bidstarz]

im liking it, i think swap rioli for sidebottom and get some DPP in the mids, overall ill rate it a 6 so far

[Justin Bieber]

im liking it, i think swap rioli for sidebottom and get some DPP in the mids, overall ill rate it a 6 so far

Wow that's a little harsh.

[jayknows]

nah i am pretty screwed unless i get some dual position in the mids, what are your thoughts whatlez?

[valkorum]

I really dislike HMac.  Has average >80 once in his career and that was when he was the only ruck in the team.  With both him and Goldy fighting for the primary duties I think this will affect his output.

[Justin Bieber]

nah i am pretty screwed unless i get some dual position in the mids, what are your thoughts whatlez?

I'll the players I dislike and I would not take.

Starter Greg Broughton - look for a Birchall or Suckling, a little more expensive, but will be worth it.

The backline is fine after that.

Jobe Watson is interesting and I'm thinking of getting instead of Barlow, I know shocking...

H Mac, had him recently and just got rid of him, I probley consider him anymore

I like choices of Mitch Robinson, cause he will fire up this year score big, but players like Rioli could be moved to Christenson to free up a bit of cash and probs will score similar.

Overall not a bad team, it's better than a 6 rating, maybe 7-8 depends on the changes you make.