Please Rate My Team Love It Or Hate It

Paulie · February 05, 2012, 09:52:04 PM

TEAM NAME: Yandismasher
DEF: H. Scotland, B. Goddard, S. Gilbert, S. Buckley, J. Grimes, M. Buntine, S. Docherty (S. Morris, B. Wilkes)
MID: S. Pendlebury, G. Ablett jnr, J. Bartel, N. Lower, A. Morabito, D. Shiel (K. Stevens, A. Treloar)
RUC: T. Goldstein, M. Leuenberger (O. Stephenson, J. Witts)
FWD: L. Franklin, N. Fyfe, J. Kennedy, J. Podsiadly, J. Porplyzia, D. Pfeiffer, I. Folau (A. Saad, D. Zorko)
CASH LEFT: $285,100

Windigo · February 05, 2012, 09:54:12 PM

Not keen on Sammy Gilbert.

I think you can do a lot better than Nick Lower in the mids! ;)

Paulie · February 05, 2012, 10:03:21 PM

cheers mate its first draft, so still playing around a bit

any suggestions on what i could replace with

Paulie · February 06, 2012, 12:21:19 AM

ammended team opinions please

bonus if someone rates out of 100 and any changes i should make

TEAM NAME: Yandismasher
DEF: H. Scotland, B. Goddard, H.Shaw, S. Buckley, A.Carrazzo, M. Buntine, S. Docherty (S. Morris, B. Wilkes)
MID: S. Pendlebury, G. Ablett jnr, L.Shiels,T.Scully, A. Morabito, D. Shiel (K. Stevens, A. Treloar)
RUC: T. Goldstein, M. Leuenberger (O. Stephenson, J. Witts)
FWD: L. Franklin, N. Fyfe, J. Kennedy, J. Podsiadly, J. Porplyzia, D. Pfeiffer, I. Folau (A. Saad, D. Zorko)
CASH LEFT: $18.800

ShaynoB · February 06, 2012, 12:33:55 AM

Quote from: Paulie on February 06, 2012, 12:21:19 AM
ammended team opinions please

bonus if someone rates out of 100 and any changes i should make

TEAM NAME: Yandismasher
DEF: H. Scotland, B. Goddard, H.Shaw, S. Buckley, A.Carrazzo, M. Buntine, S. Docherty (S. Morris, B. Wilkes)
MID: S. Pendlebury, G. Ablett jnr, L.Shiels,T.Scully, A. Morabito, D. Shiel (K. Stevens, A. Treloar)
RUC: T. Goldstein, M. Leuenberger (O. Stephenson, J. Witts)
FWD: L. Franklin, N. Fyfe, J. Kennedy, J. Podsiadly, J. Porplyzia, D. Pfeiffer, I. Folau (A. Saad, D. Zorko)
CASH LEFT: $18.800

Def - Get rid of Buckley and poss change to Marty Clarke and use the $200k elsewhere
Mid - I like Pendle as apposed to Swan & Shiels as point of difference but will he b in top 6-7 mids at the end? probs not. Watch Morabito in the NAB cup, if no good change to Clifton or Miles from GWS as both look very good
Ruck - Change Goldy to any other prem ruck, i think HMac will dent him slightly
Fwds - Fyfe, Pods and Porps are all under injury clouds so that could be very risky. Not sure if Pfeiffer is on the senior list so might want to check that to.

I would rate maybe around 70-75 out of 100. Just got a few 'to' risky players but i do like some as point of diff. Maybe a lil harsh but thats just my thought

Paulie · February 06, 2012, 01:03:02 AM

cheers shayno

i have changed some players and the team to me looks a bit more solid

opinions as always will be appreciated

TEAM NAME: Yandismasher
DEF: H. Scotland, B. Goddard, H.Shaw, M.Clarke, A.Carrazzo, M. Buntine, S. Docherty (S. Morris, B. Wilkes)
MID: S. Pendlebury, G. Ablett jnr, L.Shiels,T.Scully, A. Morabito, D. Shiel (K. Stevens, A. Treloar)
RUC: S.Mumford, M. Leuenberger (O. Stephenson, J. Witts)
FWD: L. Franklin, S.Johnson, J. Kennedy, D.Petrie, R.Nahas, D. Pfeiffer, I. Folau (A. Saad, D. Zorko)
CASH LEFT: $216.500

JBs-Hawks · February 06, 2012, 01:08:58 AM

Big risk going scully in the new GWS team, definately better options out there.

ShaynoB · February 06, 2012, 01:09:15 AM

yep looks better but just watch Morabito, Petire and Scully thru NAB.

Nice balance to the team thou

stew42 · February 06, 2012, 01:17:29 AM

I'll list your risky/poor picks:

Shiels: Won't be top 6 mids in 2012, therefore don't have him
Scully: Likewise. Would do well to average 100.
Morabito: There are rooks whowould do just as well as him.

Witts: WHERE THE FLIP IS GILES!!!???

All your fwds except for Franklin, maaaaybe Johnson and Zorko: Unless you want to be very unique, drop most of these guys. Kennedy won't average what you need. Petrie is too inconsistant and loses worth with his Ruck eligibility taken. Nahas is verry risky, look at Martin instead. Pfieif... anywho. He still needs to be elevated so keep an eye on him and have a replacement in mind if he isn't. There are better options than Folau. Saad is a crummy small fwd. Pass.

Rankings:
Backs - 7/10 -1 point because of your bye structure
Mids - 6/10
Rucks - 7/10
Fwds - 3/10

Overall 5.75/10

ShaynoB · February 06, 2012, 01:19:49 AM

Quote from: stew42 on February 06, 2012, 01:17:29 AM
I'll list your risky/poor picks:

Shiels: Won't be top 6 mids in 2012, therefore don't have him
Scully: Likewise. Would do well to average 100.
Morabito: There are rooks whowould do just as well as him.

Witts: WHERE THE FLIP IS GILES!!!???

All your fwds except for Franklin, maaaaybe Johnson and Zorko: Unless you want to be very unique, drop most of these guys. Kennedy won't average what you need. Petrie is too inconsistant and loses worth with his Ruck eligibility taken. Nahas is verry risky, look at Martin instead. Pfieif... anywho. He still needs to be elevated so keep an eye on him and have a replacement in mind if he isn't. There are better options than Folau. Saad is a crummy small fwd. Pass.

Rankings:
Backs - 7/10 -1 point because of your bye structure
Mids - 6/10
Rucks - 7/10
Fwds - 3/10

Overall 5.75/10

snap!!!! :D
haha

Paulie · February 06, 2012, 01:30:48 AM

steward any ideas on fowards advice and downgrades that are better options overall

any help is appreciated

Paulie · February 06, 2012, 02:47:04 AM

ok had enough for today have made some changes and finding it tough with the coin

dont be too harsh on me

TEAM NAME: Yandismasher
DEF: H. Scotland, B. Goddard, H.Shaw, B Deledio, A.Carrazzo, T.Mohr,X Ellis,(S. Morris, B. Wilkes)
MID: S. Pendlebury, G. Ablett jnr, L.Shiels,T.Scully, A. Morabito, D. Shiel (K. Stevens, A. Treloar)
RUC: T. Goldstein, M. Leuenberger (O. Stephenson, J. Witts)
FWD: L. Franklin, D,Beams, M,Robinson, D.Martin, A.Christensen, K.Reimers,S.Byrnes,(A.Pattinson
D.Zorko)

Justin Bieber · February 06, 2012, 02:37:35 PM

Very good backs. You need Marty Clarke though.

Mids are pretty good, haven't seen Liam Shields in my teams.. as well as Tom Scully

Strong rucks, but no Giles?

And forwards are solid with chrisso as your 5th forwards, but trade kyle reimers for someone like JB or Winderlich (even though I wouldn't), but you need to get rid of Reimers!

Paulie · February 06, 2012, 04:09:46 PM

hi Whatlez thanks for the input
i didnt list marty clarke in the tem but he is there in the backline

and giles for gws is in my rucks as a reserve atm..was that who you were talking about??

my forward line concerning reimers will need to change but am struggling to find quality player as JB is out of my reach with the setup i have

what sort of rating would my team be do you think out of 100

Paulie · February 06, 2012, 05:11:35 PM

here is updated version

TEAM NAME: Yandismasher
DEF: H. Scotland, B. Goddard, M.Clarke, B Deledio, A.Carrazzo, T.Mohr,X Ellis,(S. Morris, B. Wilkes)
MID: S. Pendlebury, G. Ablett jnr, B.Gibbs,K. Stevens, A. Morabito, D. Shiel (S.Ross, J.Mcdonald)
RUC: B.Mccauly, M. Leuenberger (O. Stephenson, J. Giles)
FWD: L. Franklin, D,Beams, M,Robinson, D.Martin, A.Christensen, K.Reimers,S.Byrnes,(A.Pattinson
D.Zorko)