rate team please, top10% last year

[ratbomber]

gday,  what do u think of team,

DEF: goddard, deledio, shaw, birchall, grimes, Ellis, Darley, (smedts, L brown)

MID: ablett, swan, watson, mcdonald, zorko, pfeiffer, (shiel, T Mitchell)

RUCK: mumford, jacobs, (giles, stephenson)

FORW: franklin, pav, martin, zaharakis, J Brown, tomlinson, saad, (treloar, crozier)

$9900 left,

will re-asses during nab, but think good balance throughout each position...
feed back appreciated

[baggers11]

8/10    not sure about jacobs, midfield a touch weak

[billoddie74]

I have exact same rucks and people seem to be talking up Jacobs, or talking him down, so im not sure.

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,47429.0.html

[ben_020285]

I think your setup is perfect.

I just think a couple of changes are needed to your players.

BACKS: You have 3 prems from the round 13 bye, (Goddard, Deledio, Birchall). This means you would get a donut in round 13. The Tigers have a very tough draw at the start of the season so I would swap Deledio as he is the perfect upgrade target later in the year. Adcock or Heppell are 2 worthy replacements. Grimes is a worry too, he's just so injury prone.

MIDS: I like the 3 prem setup. Not sure about Watson though, maybe Selwood would be a better choice?

RUCKS: Good setup. No changes needed.

FWDS: Pav and Martin have a very tough draw early in the season so could be better utilised as upgrade targets. I'd replace them with Rioli and a prem from either Geelong, Sydney or Collingwood.

That's my thoughts anyway.

7.5/10

[biggooters]

I think your setup is perfect.

I just think a couple of changes are needed to your players.

BACKS: You have 3 prems from the round 13 bye, (Goddard, Deledio, Birchall). This means you would get a donut in round 13. The Tigers have a very tough draw at the start of the season so I would swap Deledio as he is the perfect upgrade target later in the year. Adcock or Heppell are 2 worthy replacements. Grimes is a worry too, he's just so injury prone.

MIDS: I like the 3 prem setup. Not sure about Watson though, maybe Selwood would be a better choice?

RUCKS: Good setup. No changes needed.

FWDS: Pav and Martin have a very tough draw early in the season so could be better utilised as upgrade targets. I'd replace them with Rioli and a prem from either Geelong, Sydney or Collingwood.

That's my thoughts anyway.

7.5/10

doesnt matter if you have 3 prems out in rd13 if you have mpp