Please Rate my Team- Blue Dog

Started by FisherSaints, February 05, 2012, 04:38:38 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

FisherSaints

This is my team:

Defenders- Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Grant Birchall, Jed Adcock, Marty Clarke, Brandon Ellis, Will Sierakowski.
Bench- Jed Bews, Micheal Talia.

Midfielders- Andrew Swallow, Joel Selwood, Luke Hodge, Luke Ball, Dylan Shiel, Tom Mitchell.
Bench- Sam Docherty, Darren Pfeiffer.

Rucks- Shane Mumford, Matthew Leunberger.
Bench- Jonathan Giles, Orren Stephenson.

Forwards- Lance Franklin, Steve Johnson, Robin Nahas, Mark LeCras, Patrick Dangerfield, Ahmed Saad, Dayne Zorko.
Bench- Tommy Walsh, Hayden Croizer

$7,900 left. What do you guys think?

FisherSaints

No one has rated yet, guess it means it's to perfect and no ratings needed

Warfey

Good side but not really a fan of having lecras and nahas in your forwards
Downgrade one to a rookie and upgrade the other to a premium say Ryan okeefe?
Good gamble on dangerfield!

Only other question is on Luke ball and swallow? Could get barlow and another proven gun?

Ringo

Unique team here compared to others.

I do think however you need one of the big Mid super prem Ablett, Pendles, Swan in your team or you will be behind the eight ball.

Forward line has risks but you have probably factored that in.

7/10

Ace Manuva

I don't mind the Nahas choice. He can be a DT slut for sure. The problem is that he doesn't often get his own ball - that's his role in the team... an outside player that uses his pace - so if his team can't keep posession he's unlikely to get much of it at all. Great against the lesser teams, struggles against the top sides.
Since the tiges have 3 of last years top 4 in their first 5 matches, plus carlton in rnd 1, I expect he will go down quite a bit initially. I think he is an early target though, as after rnd 5 the tiges have the best draw in the comp. I predict big things for him this year - very high ceiling and will play every game.