Clay Smith or Dylan Shiel?

[Joel20]

I am looking for a good midfield rookie to finish my team. Or please tell me which rookies i should have instead of others?

[Purple 77]

Mostly, I'm waiting for NAB cup results. Put have heard good things from Shiel

[coolfugitiv0]

I'd go for Shiel right now. BUT, it's all gonna come down to NAB Cup/Starting 22 for round 1.
Keep your eye on these two - time will tell you which is the better choice.

[enzedder]

Mostly, I'm waiting for NAB cup results. Put have heard good things from Shiel

This.
No good finalising rookies until teams are named for Round 1.

[Bosh]

both. One on bench, one on field

[CrowsFan]

Shiel will be one of the best scoring rookies this year. You need to pick him :)