Ahmed Saad or Darren Pfeiffer?

[Joel20]

Im looking for a good foward rookie around 125k. Leave your thoughts on other rookies or why i should choose a certain rookie. Thanks.  :)

[nathan11]

pfeiffer when he gets elevated copied this about Saad from another site  Too many in front of him. At best he will snag a few goals and with Milney and the Schneider man buzzin around his job security isn’t as good as some of the other hopefuls.

[BratPack]

When he gets elevated. Phieffer, noone at Port to stop him really

[Joel20]

Fair point, i think i will stick with Pfeiffer then. Thanks :)

[MGK1]

As a Carlton supporter I've followed these 2 carefully.

Saad should have been picked up a few years ago from his time in the Bullants, but like Nathan said hes behind Milne and maybe Schneider.

Pfeiffer is an interesting one, went through the Crows, Carlton now is at Port (very familar to CURNOW!) and personally I think hes ready to be a regular. Can find the ball, averaged 23 touches in SANFL and is in a struggling side in Port. If elevated get on him!

[yorgis]

pfeiffer should get elevated- port have only one on veterans list [ cassissi ? ]

[Fenno]

Pfeiffer killed it in the SANFL last year. You would be crazy not to have him

[pavs nose]

have to go for dazza. as others have said...crap team and must have been seleted to inject some experience