Is Pendlebury the new Swan

[The F.A.R.K.]

So who would you take. Ideally both but if you could only pick one which one. Pendles was top overall scorer last year but also played more than swan.

[Justin Bieber]

I've gone pendlebury cause of his age

[elephants]

Swannie - DT

Pendles - SC

[The F.A.R.K.]

for me it is the other way round

[elephants]

Swan
DT - 121
SC - 122

Pendles
DT - 116
SC - 129

Go figure. I agree both are champions but surely Swannie is a better DTer and Pendles a better SCer.

[The F.A.R.K.]

yeah but heading into this year. If you were taking your first pick in the draft who would you take

[elephants]

What draft? For the next 5 years? Or for this year?
This year = Swan
Long term = Pendles (only cos of age)

[The F.A.R.K.]

this year only

i.e you play dt gold and you have the draft would you pick pendles or swan

[elephants]

Swan in DT
Pendles in SC

My opinion but I doubt I'm alone in thinking that.

[Ziplock]

What draft? For the next 5 years? Or for this year?
This year = Swan
Long term = Pendles (only cos of age)

euros my top 2 were
1) pendles
2) selwood

then ablett/swannie jostling for 3 :P

[Purple 77]

Swannie - DT

Pendles - SC

He speaks the truth

[pavs nose]

hmmmm. thats a tough one. i saw a pic of pendlebry and he looks fitter/beefier. swan has more tattoos.

what ever happens i think they will ave within 2 points of each other

[Purple 77]

Any chance Buckley will mix things up a bit?

[Football Factory]

Swan had a slight injury last year missed a game etc.. it affected his scores slightly .. Swan for me

[Torpedo10]

Rockliff is the new Swan. He will be the breakout of 2012, I'm tipping a 117+ avg.