Player X vs Player Y thread

[My Chumps]

Daisy/Selwood over Pendles/Shuey

Kreuzer>Maric>Smith

-------

Fyfe vs Goodes vs Stevey J vs Pav (Any 2)

Murphy vs Boyd vs Dal vs Priddis vs Judd vs Rockliff vs Watson

Pav > Goodes > Fyfe > Stevie J
Judd > Rockliff > Murphy > Watson > Boyd > Priddis > NDS

[My Chumps]

Swan vs Pendles?
Take into account the 40k price difference.

[MC]

Pendles easily. Swan will have a rest at some point - Pendles has a higher fitness level, and seems to have all the time in the world; which equates to better disposal and higher SC scores. Swan gets a lot of points from goals - if they dry up a touch, his scores will decline.

[jabroni]

does anybody believe any of the crows mid price mids will finish top 12 mids this year?

and who is better - sloane or van berlo or vince or douglas?

i know sloane has been hyped up in DT but who will be SC king for the crows besides thompson

[MC]

Thompson is the only one from Adelaide with a chance.
Dangerfield may get there in the forwards.

No one else will be a true keeper for 2012.

[Ziplock]

you don't think sloane coming into his 4th year?

went over his scores quickly, looked ridiculously consistent for the most part- an improving adelaide team, with a ridiculous draw, he might be both more consistent, and higher scoring?

[MC]

Or you might just be trying to justify bringing in a mid-price midfielder, when clearly there is more potential elsewhere. Your call mate, but this is your conscience saying "No, don't do it man!"

[TheMailman]

Or you might just be trying to justify bringing in a mid-price midfielder, when clearly there is more potential elsewhere. Your call mate, but this is your conscience saying "No, don't do it man!"

I think when you talk of potential you talk of mid-pricers, and the only mid priced player I'm going near is Sloane

[MC]

Each to their own I guess - As far as the term 'mid-price' goes  - 478k is VERY steep for a mid pricer. 70k more gets you Redden, who is almost guaranteed to outscore Sloane, as well as increase his average. If you are confident you'll keep him, and he'll be in your best 22 at the end of the season, jump on! But if you plan on trading him out at any point (barring say finals with a spare trade up your sleeve) then slap yourself and say "NO!"

[Aidans Blues]

Andrew Swallow v Scott Thompson?

[cortez]

Andrew swallow i reckon. he'll keep improving as north improve.

Chappy or dustin?

[My Chumps]

Swallow > Thompson

Dustin > Chappy

[Jay]

Andrew Swallow v Scott Thompson?

thompson just

Chappy or dustin?

dustin

Enright vs broughton?
Priddis vs Boyd vs Swallow vs Roclliff vs Thompson?

[My Chumps]

Broughton > Enright

Second one's tough...
Swallow > Rockliff > Boyd > Priddis > Thompson

Swallow, Rocky and Boyd are all pretty even IMO though.

[Ringo]

Broughton > Enright

Second one's tough...
Swallow > Rockliff > Boyd > Priddis > Thompson

Swallow, Rocky and Boyd are all pretty even IMO though.

As you can see by this poll which I set up.  Still none the wiser,

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,49300.0.html