Player X vs Player Y thread

[Jay]

Yeah past stats have cox at the top. But he cant get much better can he with nic nat increasingly getting more ruck time and him only getting older? And on the other hand mummy can only get better!? Just a thought :)

[MC]

True, like I said, it could happen!

What do you think about:

Hanley/Pendles/Stevens/Goodes  VS  Hargrave/Murphy/Redden/Brown

[roti]

Boyd V Murphy V Selwood

Pick two?

[MC]

Murphy and Boyd. You realise you're supposed to comment on at least one other X vs Y before you post your own? 

[My Chumps]

Hargrave/Murphy/Redden/Brown

Selwood/Murphy

Shiel v Clifton v JMac v Koby Stevens v Lachie Neale

[MC]

Thanks.

Imo from what i've seen/heard:

Shiel>Clifton>Stevens>JMac  (Not sure re: Neale, haven't heard anything about him)

[My Chumps]

Thanks.

Imo from what i've seen/heard:

Shiel>Clifton>Stevens>JMac  (Not sure re: Neale, haven't heard anything about him)

Watched Neale tonight playing for Freo...
Lyon apparently has hopes on him and he scored 37 DT points for not even a proper half of footy. I was impressed   ;)

[Capper]

Thanks.

Imo from what i've seen/heard:

Shiel>Clifton>Stevens>JMac  (Not sure re: Neale, haven't heard anything about him)

Watched Neale tonight playing for Freo...
Lyon apparently has hopes on him and he scored 37 DT points for not even a proper half of footy. I was impressed   ;)

but it the NAB and Lyon doesnt really like playing anyone under the age of 24 in the real deal.

Jmac>Shiel>Clifton>Stevens>Neale

Boyd over Selwood over Murphy

[MC]

How about
Cox/Horsley VS Luenberger/Caddy

[TheMailman]

How about
Cox/Horsley VS Luenberger/Caddy

Well, assumng Leunburger and Cox average the same (too hard to call)

Horsley offers more value for money (if he plays) than Caddy (Leu offers more as well)

Caddy probably offers more points than Horsely does

So I'd say depending on money,
If you have a strong midfield already go Leu Horsely but if you don't but have the money go Cox/ Caddy

[MC]

3 mid prems - so not exactly brimming with points this year... Imo Caddy will go for 80ppg and Luenberger 110 (So 190)
Cox 120 + Horsley? = ?

[TheMailman]

You'll still have to wait to see if Horsely will be elevated from the rookie list before you can talk of averages

[MC]

Yeah fair enough.

Another one:
Fyfe/Porp  vs  Danger/Brown

[Capper]

Yeah fair enough.

Another one:
Fyfe/Porp  vs  Danger/Brown

Fyfe/Porp  over  Danger/Brown

[MC]

Oh really? Any particular reasoning?