Player X vs Player Y thread

[roo boys!]

Yeah, I just see Hurley as a tough one. He can really take the next step this year and do well, but if he's floating between CHF and CHB etc...it might be a bit hard. Remembering he's still young so consistency could be a big issue.

[CrowsFan]

Yeah if he plays down back I don't think he will score well, but doubt he will with players like Pears etc to come back in to the defense, they don't really need him there...

[Aidans Blues]

Goodes or Chapman

[coolfugitiv0]

Goodes or Chapman

Chappy to start.
Goodes to bring home the goodes in the second half of the year.

[Capper]

Goodes or Chapman

Chappy to start.
Goodes to bring home the goodes in the second half of the year.

Really???? Goodes plays against GWS, Freo, @Port, NM, @Hawks(tassie), Crows, @Tigers and Dees in the first 8 rounds and will score as much as he wants. Chappy has @Freo, Hawks, NM, Tigers, @Lions, Dees, @Crows, Pies.

I would have Goodes and Chappy/Stevie J from the start in my team

[coolfugitiv0]

Goodes or Chapman

Chappy to start.
Goodes to bring home the goodes in the second half of the year.

Really???? Goodes plays against GWS, Freo, @Port, NM, @Hawks(tassie), Crows, @Tigers and Dees in the first 8 rounds and will score as much as he wants. Chappy has @Freo, Hawks, NM, Tigers, @Lions, Dees, @Crows, Pies.

I would have Goodes and Chappy/Stevie J from the start in my team

Just going on trends from past years where Goodes tears it up during the latter part of the season - no matter who the opposition is.
However, Chappy has had a ripper pre-season so far, and has gotten rid of the niggles that troubled him last year. So he's a lock for me for the start.

Just my personal opinion, hey, I might turn out to be completely wrong!

[Capper]

Goodes or Chapman

Chappy to start.
Goodes to bring home the goodes in the second half of the year.

Really???? Goodes plays against GWS, Freo, @Port, NM, @Hawks(tassie), Crows, @Tigers and Dees in the first 8 rounds and will score as much as he wants. Chappy has @Freo, Hawks, NM, Tigers, @Lions, Dees, @Crows, Pies.

I would have Goodes and Chappy/Stevie J from the start in my team

Just going on trends from past years where Goodes tears it up during the latter part of the season - no matter who the opposition is.
However, Chappy has had a ripper pre-season so far, and has gotten rid of the niggles that troubled him last year. So he's a lock for me for the start.

Just my personal opinion, hey, I might turn out to be completely wrong!

I was of the same opinion with Goodes but you must start him in my opinion this year

[sidvicious]

goodes> chapman

Dylan Shiel , Koby Stevens , Stephen Clifton , James McDonald

[MC]

Shiel>Clifton>Old McDonald>Stevens


Rioli/Martin/Nroo  VS   Buddy/Goodes/Christensen

Redden/Wingard(or Morabito)   VS    Rockliff/Clay Smith

[sidvicious]

buddy > rioli
goodes>martin
Nroo> christensen
so buddy goodes christensen

redden moribito

L.Brown , S Morris , B.Wilkes

[Capper]

Dylan Shiel over James McDonald over Stephen Clifton over Koby Stevens

But i will be gettting mc and Shiel

buddy > rioli
goodes>martin
Nroo> christensen
so buddy goodes christensen

+1

redden over moribito

B.Wilkes over L.Brown over S Morris

[Jay]

Sandi vs cox vs mummy

Goodes vs pav vs martin vs chappy

[MC]

Cox>Mummy>Sandi   --> Cox is the best, and will continue to be.

Goodes>Martin>Pav>Chappy  --> Goodes will tear up this year, and has missed 3 game sin like 11 years. Martin to step up to perhaps 110 avg this year, and Pav over Chappy because of durability.

[Jay]

Cox>Mummy>Sandi   --> Cox is the best, and will continue to be.

Goodes>Martin>Pav>Chappy  --> Goodes will tear up this year, and has missed 3 game sin like 11 years. Martin to step up to perhaps 110 avg this year, and Pav over Chappy because of durability.

You dont think mummy can pass cox???

[MC]

Oh yeah, he could, but have a look at the stats from the past which suggest Cox is still there for now.