Player X vs Player Y thread

[alexross]

Porps but you must shoulder the risk.

If i could give you a cheer for that somment i would.

Broughton over Enright

Porps over Rohan

Lids over Fyfe

[Capper]

Rookie rucks

Giles v Stephensen v Gorringe v Derrickx???

[tor01doc]

Exactly.

Giles and Stephenson seems to be in most teams and for a reason.

Gorringe is 2nd year and either 2nd =or 3rd line after Smith +/- Fraser.

Derickxs - last by a fair margin I would have thought.

[Cruiseon]

J Watson v L Hodge v Deludio (as a mid) ?????

I'm leaning to Jobe but not by much.

Thoughts? 

[tor01doc]

I'd be wary of Hawks' first 6 games (Coll/Gee/Ade/WCE/Syd/Stk) and same for Lids (Carl/Coll/Mel/Gee/WCE) and his possible hammy.

So Jobe and look to get one or both of the others later.

What about ROK?

[Colliwobblers]

roks a LOT dearer.

watson over hodge just and both over delids by a fair bit unless u start him in your mids and later move him to your backs. and upgrade a rook to a real mid

heres one and all these guys are super guns but you may not know them all

[rookie listed rookies]

Mark Baguley(ESS) , Pfeiffer(PORT) , Mcintyre(ADE) , Spurr(FRE) , Horsley(GCS) , Magner(MEL) , Gibson(NM) , Greenwood(WB)

sorry thats a bit more than x and y but unlikely anyone else will consider the rookie listed gems..

[tor01doc]

No no no..not Rockliffe. I meant R O'K.

[Colliwobblers]

No no no..not Rockliffe. I meant R O'K.

LOL my bad should have realised, RoK should smash it with the easxy first half of thier draw as a long term prospect not sure but he did well last season all season long. so often overlooked i wasnt planning to or expecting to but he was one of my last upgrades ;ast season was going so well was he

[alexross]

Sidebottom v dangerfield v zaha

[tor01doc]

Zaha > Dangermouse > sidehole

[c4v3m4n]

Sidebottom v dangerfield v zaha

Zaha > Dangerfield > Sidebottom IMO.

Zaha had a massive breakout season including winning Essendon's B&F, should he improve further, watch out. Dangerfield could be set for a breakout season himself pushing his average into the 90s, and Sidebottom is a hard one to judge in such a domimant side.

Barlow, Giles and Porplyzia VS. Clifton, McEvoy and Saad?

[Capper]

Sidebottom v dangerfield v zaha

Zaha > Dangerfield > Sidebottom IMO.

Zaha had a massive breakout season including winning Essendon's B&F, should he improve further, watch out. Dangerfield could be set for a breakout season himself pushing his average into the 90s, and Sidebottom is a hard one to judge in such a domimant side.

Barlow, Giles and Porplyzia VS. Clifton, McEvoy and Saad?

Sidebottom > Zaha > Dangerfield

Barlow > Clifton
Porplyzia > Saad
McEvoy > Giles

so Barlow, Giles and Porplyzia over Clifton, McEvoy and Saad

[CrowsFan]

Martin and Zaha or Goodes and Hurley?

[roo boys!]

Martin and Zaha.

[CrowsFan]

Yeah that's what I had originally, but then started thinking that Goodes has a much higher ceiling than Martin, and Hurley could have a big yeah, apparently been training very well...