Player X vs Player Y thread

[Sparxx]

Hodge for me, coming from a Hawthorn supporter :)

Birchall vs. Broughton

[Capper]

Cox over sandi over mummy over Nic nat

watson over hodge - the bombers rely more on watson than the hawks on hodge

Broughton over Birchal

[Jay]

Hodge for me, coming from a Hawthorn supporter :)

Birchall vs. Broughton

broughton mate

[enzedder]

Hodge for me, coming from a Hawthorn supporter :)

Birchall vs. Broughton

Broughton

Grimes v Heppell v Johncock

[Purple 77]

Sandi over Mummy over Cox over Nic Nat

Watson over Hodge

Broughton over Birchall

Grimes over Heppell over Johncock

[Jay]

Heppel > grimes > stiffy

-------
Nic nat vs Jacobs??

[ando_10]

jacobs


swan vs Pendles vs Thomas

[Aidans Blues]

Jacobs over NicNat

Pendles over Swan over Thomas

Grimes/Porplyzia v M.Clarke/Zaharakis

[ando_10]

grimes and porps by a mile IMO

[Jay]

Wow Jacobs over nic nat??? Reasons?

Jacobs over NicNat

Pendles over Swan over Thomas

Grimes/Porplyzia v M.Clarke/Zaharakis

grimes and porps imo

[Aidans Blues]

Its a tough one but Jacobs will be number one ruck, without a lot of other rucks taking points off him. Theyre both reasonable picks but i think Jacobs just..

[Purple 77]

Jacobs over Nic Nat

Pendles over Swan over Thomas

Grimes/Porpoise over Clarke/Zaharakis (just)

[ando_10]

im with aiden all the ruck work will be done by jacobs for the crows where as you would think cox would be main ruckman and you would think nic nat will be down forward majority of the time

[Jay]

Okay thanks guy...you've convinced me :D which begs the question jacobs vs kreuzer???

swan vs Pendles vs Thomas

pendles if $$$ isnt a worry

[Maca24]

Kreuzer > Jacobs.

I like Kreuzers MPP and Jacobs doesnt jump at me like most.

Dangerfield vs Cloke? Leunberger vs McEvoy vs NicNat?

Sorry I have two :P