Player X vs Player Y thread

Started by Jay, February 04, 2012, 03:31:43 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

oconnell

Selwood vs M Murphy vs Judd vs Dal Santo vs Rockliff

Purple 77


Buddy over D-Mart over Cyril over Pav over Chappy over Stevie J

Martin started off with a bang last year, could do it this season also...


J Selwood over M Murphy over Judd over Rockliff over Dal Santo

(think Dal might start slowly this year... just a feeling)

Sparxx


Purple 77

Quote from: Sparxx on February 04, 2012, 05:37:17 PM
Kreuzer vs. West vs. McIntosh

Should give your opinions on other's first....

But... Kreuze over McIntosh over West (West a bit of an unknown...)

cortez

Kruze!!! If he can play anywhere near what he is cspable will definately be a prem by the end the year.

Kruze >Hmac > west

cortez


Purple 77

Quote from: cortez on February 04, 2012, 05:42:14 PM
Buddy vs Fyfe vs Goodes

^ in that order for me :) Though not 100% sure Fyfe will back up again this year, but he looks a star

SonsOfZeus

Quote from: oconnell on February 04, 2012, 05:29:46 PM
Selwood vs M Murphy vs Judd vs Dal Santo vs Rockliff

selwood-murphy-rockliff-judd- dalsanto

Richooo

selwood  -dalsanto - murphy - judd - rockliff

broughton vs suckling

Purple 77


Broughton over Suckling, never been convinced on Suckling... maybe this year having said that

Aidans Blues

Broughton for me also.

Beams or Zaharakis?

Purple 77


I'd say Zaharakis, Beams I feel is overpriced...

Capper

Selwood over Judd over M Murphy over Dal Santo over Rockliff

Kreuzer over McIntosh over West

Goodes over Buddy over Fyfe

broughton over suckling

Beams over Zaharakis

Jay

Quote from: Aidans Blues on February 04, 2012, 07:39:52 PM
Broughton for me also.

Beams or Zaharakis?
beams for me

----
Cox vs sandi vs mummy vs. Nic nat

nathan11

Quote from: cortez on February 04, 2012, 05:42:14 PM
Buddy vs Fyfe vs Goodes

goodes, fyfe buddy for me goodes 1st because of early draw, same reason i put buddy 3rd can see him dropping in price early on

hodge vs watson?