please help me with my team

Started by washemj21, February 03, 2012, 11:31:50 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

washemj21

DEF: b.deledio, b.goddard, d.heppell, c.enright, b.houli, J.townsend, s.morris (l.brown, b.wilkes)
MID: g.ablett, j.selwood, s.pendlebury, a.kennedy, d.zorko, s.ross (j.mcdonald, t.mitchell)
RUCK: b.mcevoy, d.cox (j.giles, o.stephenson)
FWD: chappy, b.franklin, a.goodes, m.robinson, l.adams, t.walsh, a.treloar (s.rowe, s.kerridge)

i have 6k left in the kitty

NOTE: updated players are in bold

Jimbo_11

solid backline, apart from lake, no so sure he will be able to regain his form and scoring this year, maybe a possible upgrade target later on if he fires up

theres gotta be better midpricers in the mids than didak, maybe look at barlow or another premo with all the xtra cash you have
and koby stevens??

im not convinced of mcevoy's ability to pump out big scores week in week out, theres other more consistent options

chappy is a risk, but also high reward, who knows how much longer he has left
roo is also a huge risk but also huge reward, too bad im not too convinced he will be able to do it

washemj21

in regards to lake ive been monitoring his progress and if he doesnt got o well in the nab cup ive got other options waiting.
i put didak in the mids as he is a mid forward and so i can swap him round with the others. i believe in mcevoy and he improved so much last year that i think he can take another step up again this year.
accordin to the geelong website chappy has been firin this preseason and he didnt do so well l;ast yr because his pre season was interuppted. koby stevens is likely to get some games for the eagles as i think i heard embley got injured. i have lots of back ups ready for my midpricers if they dont do well in the nab cup

Jimbo_11

theres still gotta be better rooks than koby stevens

shiel? kerridge? clifton? take ya pick

washemj21

is koby stevens actually that bad, but ill see how he goes in the nab cup. all rookies r not guarenteed atm

Justin Bieber

Solid team, but your spine of your team (Midfield) is lacking in places.

FRAZLER

Didak is too much of a risk and will spend most of his time in the forward half which will effecthis scoring. Pies have so many midfield options that the days of dids scoring well are over IMO. Solid side tho if u can turn dids into a premo

yorgis

put dids in forwards for nroo or fyfe and thompson in mids [crows]

washemj21

i only have didiak in the midfield so i have a link between my forward and midfield. also i think didak had a bit of an interuppted pre season last year and i dont think thats the case this year.

yorgis

he's taking a spot of a prem mid. zorko and treloar are your mid/for links

washemj21

is this better?
DEF: scotland, birchall, heppell, hanley, lake, aylett, morris (smedts, wilkes)
MID: ablett, stanton, goddard, selwood, zorko, k.stevens (mcdonald, l.brown)
RUCK: mcevoy, jacobs (stephenson, giles)
FWD: franklin, chapman, fyfe, robinson, didak, walsh, treloar ( rowe, couch)

$54k left

Maverick

good team, but i think that stanton should upgraded to Thompson, or someone of the like. I think that going with Thompson there will be much less risk and also a much greater reward. Didak seems to have a good pre-season as well but i think that he is not going to score well, as all he does in games is score miraculous goals.

washemj21

i think didak will go better this yr as, as i said, his pre season wasnt interuppted this year. i have to many rookies from rd 11 teams bye to have thompson and stanton can score as much as him.

Flame

I have Didak and hope he comes good. Thompson would be a good pick. Good side!

Watto

like the points of difference across Hanley/Mundy/Jacobs , but especially with Mundy and his price, be careful who you go for. Could easily play it a bit safer and go for Bartel/Cross/Hodge for similar prices if you want a perhaps safer option

good to see a solid amount left in the kitty as well

and yes I reckon Didak in forwards is better than midfield