The Supercoach has Started 2012, PLEASE rate

[The Supercoach]

Hey guys could you rate this team and give feedback. cheers :D

Backs: Goddard, Scotland, Lids, Birchall, Grimes, Clarke, Smedts, Mohr and Morris

Mids: Ablett, Selwood, S. Thompson, Hayes, Shiel, Haynes Pfeiffer and L. Brown

Rucks: Mummy, Giles Stephenson, Derickx

Fwd: Franklin, Pav, Martin, Brown, NROO, Saad, Zorko Walsh and Hampton (not really sure on which fwd rookies to get)

I have 33k in the bank and hopefully have good rookies by the time the NAB cup finishes.

Please Rate, Thanks

[The Supercoach]

any suggestions?

[PICCOLLO]

Would rather barlow than hayes.
Shaw a more consistent player than birchall.
Good to see someone with nroo.  We quickly forget how good he can be.
The rest is unfaultable and a matter of preference.