Mad Max's 3rd Draft Where Can I Improve and Where are you different and Why?

Started by Madmax75, February 03, 2012, 07:58:22 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Madmax75

This is my 3rd draft and prety happy with it pre NAB cup. I had T CLoke in the team but at the moment have Stevie J as Im trying to stay away from key position players and as a PIes man dont want to put the moz on the human tank this year after a breakout year last year. I have highlighted the players that I have some question marks over such as Hurn, but is there anyone better at his price. THe rookies I think are standard at the moment unless someone has any other thoughts. Ive gone for the proven guns rookies strategy and have 61k in the bank. I thought not having more than one premium from the same team in the same line was a good idea even though I was tempted to have Newman or S FIsher in the backs. ANy thoughts most appreciated:

B Goddard Deledio Sucklng Hurn Clarke MOhr Whiley Allen Heath.
C Ablett Swan Murphy Barlow Shiel Brown McDonald Mitchell
R Mumford Goldstein Giles Stevenson
F Franklin S JOhnson Martin Didak J Brown Zorko Treloar Kerridge Rowe

PICCOLLO

Ditch hurn, upgrade suckling. 
How come didak isnt in bold?  He's as iffy as hurn imo.  Porps instead of dids?

Madmax75

Hurn out fair call but for who and then suckling to ?? Seems like all the other decent backs would give me 2 premiums from the same team Newman Fisher .. I think if Didak is fit then he is one of the best mid forwards options around. If he's back to 80 per cent of his 2010 form then he's a lock. But yep should have been in bold. Porps would seem to have more injury history than didak so I prob wouldnt go with him. Thanks for your feedback

SonsOfZeus

Quote from: PICCOLLO on February 04, 2012, 12:02:20 AM
Ditch hurn, upgrade suckling. 
How come didak isnt in bold?  He's as iffy as hurn imo.  Porps instead of dids?

agree with the ditch, but if didak is fit, hurn isnt in the same category.

rucks are good but cannot believe i am still seeing teams without sandi. will be the highest ruckmen this year again.

pretty solid team tho bro

Madmax75

Thanks I think it just needs a bit of tinkering will do so and post mark iv team.

Madmax75

Ok Team Mark IV. Changes are:

Hurn/Suckling out H Shaw (leadership spot to put him right?) /Broughton (If he plays mid for at least some time in NAB Cup)
Good or bad move?

Mumford/Goldstein out Sandilands/Berger in. Byes mean Mumford/Sandi Berger/Goldstein not a wise combo
Good or bad move?

Any thoughts most appreciated