2nd crack, need advice - PICTURE FORMAT

Started by Sparxx, February 03, 2012, 07:42:14 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Sparxx



What can you guys suggest for this side? I've put a lot of thought into the team, and I still have an okay amount of cash left over for mid-season trades. I'm fairly happy with it, but are there any glaring faults to the team?

Please rate :)

CrowsFan

Honestly can't find many faults wrong with that team. I guess if I were you I would put Luke Brown in the defense in place of Smedts then pick up a stronger mid rookie. Although that is just being picky ;)

Sparxx

Actually yeah thats true. I'm not completely sold on either of Walsh or Crozier as my forward reserves, and I think Smedts will get lots of game time for Geelong so I could move him to the forwards and Brown to the back.

PICCOLLO

Not sold on kreuzer but that team is at least an 8.5/10 (excluding rookies)
Enright and birchall will be bargains at some stage during the year because they have the odd low game.  Shaw/Fisher might be better choices because they're more consistent? Personal preference really.  I like your mpp links.  Nice work.

The Supercoach

Pretty good team mate the only fault i would say it has is when it comes to round 12 u have 5 people not playing in the back and 5 not playing in the fwd so there will be a few donuts so maybe try to get a bit more of a spread of round 12 and 13 bye players so u can avoid as many donuts. But if 1 round dosent worry u then ur team is very good. and by the way how do u post ur team in pic format  ???

gotheroos!

i would also move deledio to the back instead of enright as deledio is wasting the space of a good midfielder who can easily outscore enright. instead of wasting trades later, make that change now and get a rookie in mids with a dpp if necessary (e.g allen from gcs)

SonsOfZeus

definately have to have deledio in the backs to have an ultra prem in the mid.

Sparxx

Which premium midfielder is the best under $575k

The Supercoach


Birry


The Supercoach


Birry

577k surely you can find 2k somewhere, but thanks for telling me :) Would have to be Jobe then

Capper

All your backs have byes r12 and R13. This could be tricky for you. 3 prem mids have the bye in R13.

I would rather see Lids in the backs

Apart from that not bad

Sparxx

OK, so I've rejigged the team around an I've gone with the trusty 8-11-11 bye setup, with a few swingmen set in place (Aylett and Goddard will swap around to make it 2-2-2-2 on the bench with byes). Also, what does everyone think of Jimmy Bartel? I decided to go with him instead of someone a few thousand dollars more expensive so I'm left with an okay amount of cash left over (I had the option of anyone under $575k, which means Jobe, Pav, Gibbs etc.)




Capper

i would swap out Dfeiffer for walsh, and Couch for Mitchell (dont think he will start for the swans for a while)