five backs or five fowards

Started by lordy9, February 03, 2012, 07:15:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

my Question is is it better to have five pro defenders or five pro fowards?

five defenders
five fowards

lordy9


upthemaidens


Justin Bieber

I would say forwards, but is that including Chapman and Stevie J? Or is it like Franklin, Goodes, Fyfe, Pav, Robbo, Martin, Zaha etc.?

lordy9

my foward line atm is steve j franklin fyfe sidebum martin

Justin Bieber

Hit up Robbo for a fourth. People are also keen on advising Goodes. So I'm not sure cause I've pretty much traded my shuffled all the top forwards in and out of my top side.

upthemaidens

just look at last years averages,,
the 5th best defender, was around low 90's..  where as 5th best forward was probably around high 90's

Holz

backs for me, i see value in grimes and waters and everyone knows goddard and lids will be top 5 backs and im putting adcock will be too.


IM not sure about the forwards and i see more value in the rookies.

Chelskiman

Backs for me as well.  It's easier to find a forward upgrade than a back upgrade (at least it was last year).

AndrewY

Sounds like we are all having the white, the off white, the cream , ivory and beige jackets.

Kuruki

Quote from: Chelskiman on February 03, 2012, 07:33:09 PM
Backs for me as well.  It's easier to find a forward upgrade than a back upgrade (at least it was last year).

The reason it was hard to find a back upgrade was becoz it was hardly an upgrade from a rookie to a premo in terms of scoring. Backs were shyt.

upthemaidens

Quote from: Kuruki on February 03, 2012, 10:27:43 PM
Quote from: Chelskiman on February 03, 2012, 07:33:09 PM
Backs for me as well.  It's easier to find a forward upgrade than a back upgrade (at least it was last year).

The reason it was hard to find a back upgrade was becoz it was hardly an upgrade from a rookie to a premo in terms of scoring. Backs were shyt.
thats why i stayed with lower,stanley and heppell  , it just wasnt worth the trade

Tom_16

5 forwards. There is much better value in the fwd premos than the back premos.

Jukes

I got 6 forwards lol...so much goods to offer up front. Stevie J, Buddy, Beams, Zaharakis, Martin and Brown. Pro.

Scrads

#13
Since this thread, Ive edited my team to 3.5 premiums in the backline (the .5 is Grimes) and 5 in the forward line. ALong with 1 in the ruck, and 4.5 in the midfield (Barlow is the .5 there)

So all up I have 13 premiums + Barlow + Grimes. Wise or not wise ?

EDIT: have 105k up the sleeve atm too.

ShaynoB

Quote from: Scrads on February 04, 2012, 12:18:33 AM
Since this thread, Ive edited my team to 3.5 premiums in the backline (the .5 is Grimes) and 5 in the forward line. ALong with 1 in the ruck, and 4.5 in the midfield (Barlow is the .5 there)

So all up I have 13 premiums + Barlow + Grimes. Wise or not wise ?

EDIT: have 105k up the sleeve atm too.

Yeah I like!! I like very much. If Grimes works out then u have 4 anyways in the back. I was thinking of doing the same but how do u have 100k left over?