Throwing my first team out there

Started by tferrier18, February 02, 2012, 10:57:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

tferrier18

See what you think - I'm not committed or sold on this team, just whipped it together today. Obviously rookies are subject to change, players like bower mundy and burgoyne need to be monitored.

goddard, deledio, yarran, burgoyne, clarke, bower, ellis (Smedts, L. Brown)

Pendles, Ablett, Mundy, Cross, Kavanagh, Docherty (McDonald, Kerridge)

Jacobs, West (Orren, Rowe)

Franklin, Fyfe, Chapman, Martin, Brown, Porps, Walsh (Zorko, Devon Smith)

North Melbournes Finest

Trent West isn't really a supercoach player is he? He seems more of the good tap out ruckmen, does a lot of work around the ground that goes un noticed and not supercoach points. Might bob up for a goal now and then but mostly won't get too many SC points.

tferrier18

Yeah he did well whenever he played without ottens last year though. Just before seeing this comment I did swap him for giles though - came out like this.

Goddard, deledio, broughton, yarran, clarke, bower, ellis (Smedts, Brown)

Pendles, Ablett, Selwood, Cross, docherty, kavanagh (mcdonald, kerridge)

Mumford, Giles (Rowe, Orren)

Franklin, Fyfe, Chaps, Martin, Brown, Porps, Walsh (Zorko, Devon Smith)

Better ja?


Big_Cox14

Mumford & Giles is much better structurally than Jacobs & West IMO.

As you said Bower needs to be monitored. I'll be keeping an eye on him too during NAB cup  ;)

Overall a good spread around the park.

SydneyRox

Mummy is a lock for SC, I like Jacobs too if you feel like the two premium rucks.

Yarran and the Porps worry me, but respectable choices.

Mozza3

Good team, I'd be tempted to drop Chappy and have Jacobs along Mummy in the rucks. While Chappy is still a good player I just think he'll get rested now and then.