A few questions

[Jay]

Please answer these questions...would be appreciated

1. Docherty...will he play?

2. Beams??? As good as goodes/pav/stevie?

3. Nroo???

4. Are there any def/fwd mpp's (apart from smedts)?

5. Lake, clarke and bower all starting...this acceptable?

Would be great if i could get some answers to some of these Qs...thanks in advance

[CrowsFan]

4. Are there any def/fwd mpp's (apart from smedts)?

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,46394.0.html ;)

[gotheroos!]

maybe
no
no
not sure
yes

[Jay]

4. Are there any def/fwd mpp's (apart from smedts)?

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,46394.0.html ;)

aha thanks :) u know which ones will play?

maybe
no
no
not sure
yes

who would you take instead of beams then...same goes for riewoldt, who is better??? Here is my team: http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,46721.0.html

[ando_10]

1) at this stage ill say not straight away
2) will be good but not even close to the same catergory
3) yep good price i say get him
4) refer to crow fans post
5) yep no problem there

[cortez]

1. will be an upgrade target
2. na  not close yet
3. risk depending on his knees and if he can remake himself to play the new style of play
4. tomlinson from gws
5. can lake get back in form and will the other two get regular games? big risk to play all three

[Jay]

1) at this stage ill say not straight away
2) will be good but not even close to the same catergory
3) yep good price i say get him
4) refer to crow fans post
5) yep no problem there

yes i agree docherty isnt the best option but i have luke brown in mids sooooo is it worth keeping him?
Okay maybe not beams...who would you grab around that price? (have buddy and d-mart)
Yep nroo locked and loaded

1. will be an upgrade target
2. na  not close yet
3. risk depending on his knees and if he can remake himself to play the new style of play
4. tomlinson from gws
5. can lake get back in form and will the other two get regular games? big risk to play all three

Is docherty a complete no-go? Coz i need that dpp with mids
Who would you take instead of beams?
Nroo is a risk...........could be a good one tho
Okay is tomlinson gonna play?
Those three is a concern could pay off....but very risky


Thanks very much :)

[Jay]

Cant find tomlinson???? Its either hamling...staley...pattinson OR none at all and forget the mpp :/

[CrowsFan]

Is docherty a complete no-go? Coz i need that dpp with mids

Thanks very much :)

If you want a rookie def/mid I would pick up Luke Brown from Adelaide. Should slot in to the team with ease ;)

[CrowsFan]

Cant find tomlinson???? Its either hamling...staley...pattinson OR none at all and forget the mpp :/

You're looking at the Ruck/Forwards ;)
The def/forwards are:
Michael Johnson - $390,800
Brent Staker - $326,900
Lachlan Hansen - $310,300
Shaun McKernan - $272,700
Jayden Post - $259,500
Adam Tomlinson - $156,600
Jackson Ferguson - $113,200
Billie Smedts - $113,200
Tom Curran - $106,600
Jackson Paine - $106,600
Trent Stubbs - $106,600
Jack Redpath - $94,700
Simon Tunbridge - $94,700

[Jay]

Is docherty a complete no-go? Coz i need that dpp with mids

Thanks very much :)

If you want a rookie def/mid I would pick up Luke Brown from Adelaide. Should slot in to the team with ease ;)

yeah i have brown in my mids...and i think docherty is best other def/mid

Cant find tomlinson???? Its either hamling...staley...pattinson OR none at all and forget the mpp :/

You're looking at the Ruck/Forwards ;)
The def/forwards are:
Michael Johnson - $390,800
Brent Staker - $326,900
Lachlan Hansen - $310,300
Shaun McKernan - $272,700
Jayden Post - $259,500
Adam Tomlinson - $156,600
Jackson Ferguson - $113,200
Billie Smedts - $113,200
Tom Curran - $106,600
Jackson Paine - $106,600
Trent Stubbs - $106,600
Jack Redpath - $94,700
Simon Tunbridge - $94,700

Ohhh yeah wrong section...so is tomlinson a good pick???...while we're on the ruc/fwd topic, are any of hamling, staley or pattinson worth picking up?

[Jay]

So as result of the answers ive recieved.....ill keep docherty in my backs as mpp with brown

i have brought in steveJ and pav for nroo and beams

Given up on finding another def fwd mpp

and im still unsure about lake clarke and bower????

[Capper]

Cant find tomlinson???? Its either hamling...staley...pattinson OR none at all and forget the mpp :/

You're looking at the Ruck/Forwards ;)
The def/forwards are:
Michael Johnson - $390,800
Brent Staker - $326,900
Lachlan Hansen - $310,300
Shaun McKernan - $272,700
Jayden Post - $259,500
Adam Tomlinson - $156,600
Jackson Ferguson - $113,200
Billie Smedts - $113,200
Tom Curran - $106,600
Jackson Paine - $106,600
Trent Stubbs - $106,600
Jack Redpath - $94,700
Simon Tunbridge - $94,700

Tom Curran is a possible to start this year

[Jay]

More likely to play than mohr???

[Capper]

no go with Mohr