Post ur team, and I will give feedback and rate it out of 100

[oc16]

Hey guys, post ur team, and I will give some feedback and rate it out of 100. All are welcome

Heres my team and u can be the judge if u think I know or dont know what im talking about. u are also welcome to rate it if u wish.

Backs-
Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Heppell, Birchall, Clarke, Ellis (Mohr, Blee)

Mids-
Ablett, Swan, Barlow, Zorko, Shiel, Miles (Brown, Tyson)

Rucks-
Sandilands, Leuenberger (Giles, Stephensen)

Forwards-
Franklin, Robinson, Zaharakis, Sidebottom, Christensen, Pfeiffer, Treloar (Walsh, Rowe)

167,400k left over

[Chelskiman]

Ok, I'll bite...

[owenbond007]

TEAM NAME: owentest
DEF: B. Goddard, B. Deledio, D. Heppell, B. Lake, M. Clarke, T. Mohr, S. Darley (S. Morris, B. Smedts)
MID: G. Ablett jnr, J. Selwood, J. Watson, A. Swallow, M. Barlow, L. Hayes (A. Miles, K. Stevens)
RUC: A. Sandilands, J. Giles (S. Rowe, O. Stephenson)
FWD: P. Chapman, A. Goodes, D. Martin, S. Sidebottom, J. Brown, J. Porplyzia, A. Treloar (T. Walsh, D. Zorko)
CASH LEFT: $18,200

Team structure:

Byes: 3/3/3 - 3/3/2 - 1/2/1 - 4/4/1 = 11/12/7

Ignore order of rookies zorko prob start maybe smedts too.

[oc16]

Chelskiman

Backline-
Solid backline, only thing is im not too sure about hanley. i would recommend going for heppell instead, hes only about 20k more expensive but he has a lot more upside.

8.8/10

Mids-
Average, go for Barlow instead of shuey. they are the same price but barlow should average at least 10 points more. I also recommend going for someone like Dylan Shiel instead of hampton.
7.2/10


Rucks-
Very solid, cant fault it. 9.5/10

Forwards-
Good, but Patton isnt going to be playing until april due to injury so u wouldnt want to start with him unless u want to shoot urself in the foot.
8/10

84 out of 100

[Chelskiman]

Yeah, cheers.  I was told about Patto about 30 minutes ago.  Any suggestions on who to bring in for him?

[oc16]

owenbond007

Backs-
Solid. i do respect u for going with lake and i can see the appeal, however i would personally go for grimes instead. but of course u would need to have some more cash for this. this could be done by saving some cash elsewhere, preferably ur mids.

9.2/10

Mids-
Ok, but 1 or 2 too many premiums. if i was u i would choose out of swallow and watson, and then trade the other for a rookie like Mitchell (Syd), Shiel, Clifton, Tyson, or Brown.

8/10

Rucks-
Good, but u would obviously just want to make sure that rowe is fit come round 1, and going to play.

8.6/10

Forwards-
Some good unique premiums in goodes and chappy. and they should still both average around 95, and i have heard chappy is one of the standouts for the cats this pre season. however im still not sold on brown and porpz, as u can see im going for someone like christensen instead.

9/10


87 out of 100

[jballstars]

trealor for patto is 1 option

[Jalapeno]

Hey mate what do you think?

Defenders:
B Goddard
M Suckling
P Hanley
J Grimes
B Waters
M Buntine
M Clarke
Subs:
T Bugg
B Wilkes

Mids:
D Swan
J Selwood
S Thompson
L Shuey
S Coniglio
M Hallahan
Subs
D Shiel
A Treloar

Ruck:
M Leuenberger
M Kreuzer
Subs:
J Giles
O Stephensen

Forwards:
L Franklin
D Beams
N Fyfe
D Martin
A Christensen
T Milera
D Zorko
Subs:
A Saad
B Smedts

Regards

Jalapeno

[oc16]

Yeah, cheers.  I was told about Patto about 30 minutes ago.  Any suggestions on who to bring in for him?

Heres some for u to have a look at-

Saad (Stk)
Treloar (GWS)
Rowe (Carl)
Folau (GWS)
Lamb (Syd)

[pigden]

Other thing is Chelski - your 4 defensive premiums all have the bye in r13. Just something to think about.

[jemi]

BACKS: Scotland, H; Goddard, B; Deledio, B; Waters, B; Grimes, J; Clarke, M; Bugg, T; (Morris, S; Mulligan, J)
MID: Ablett, G; Chapman, P; Simpson, K; Barlow, M; Morabito, A; Smith, D; (Shiel, D; Brown, L)
RUCK: Sandilands, A; Leuenberger, M; (Giles, J; Stephenson, O)
FWD: Beams, D; Martin, D; Riewoldt, N; Christensen, A; Brown, J; Winderlich, J; Pfelffer, D; (Zorko, D; Treloar, A)

Remaining Salary: $39, 700

Any suggestions would be much appreciated

Cheers

[Chelskiman]

Other thing is Chelski - your 4 defensive premiums all have the bye in r13. Just something to think about.

I did think of that, but I'm only going for league, and I assume most of the people in my league will be hit hard as well (hopefully).

[Just Clancy]

DEFS: Goddard, Deledio, Suckling, Waters, Grimes, Connors, M. Clarke, (Smedts, Morris)
MIDS: Swan, Ablett, Selwood, Barlow, Miles, Shiel (Brown, Kavanagh)
RUCKS: Sandilands, Leuenberger (Giles, Stephensen)
FWDS: Franklin, Zaharakis, Martin, Brown, Porplyzia, Byrnes, Hampton (Zorko, Treloar)

This is the first draft of my team. I'd be happy to know what other people think of it.  :D

$60 300 left.

[oc16]

Jalapeno

backs-
good, but i would recommend getting rid of either; waters, grimes, or hanley, and getting heppell. however u havnt told me how much money u have left so i dont know if u can afford him. anyway heppell is much less of a risk, and should get some time in the essendon midfield. also mohr is probs a better option then buntine as he is about 35k cheaper and is more likely to play most games.

7.8/10

mids-
one of the more unique midfields ive seen. however if ur going to pick shuey he would need to average at least 100, which is possible. however someone like barlow is a much safer option.

9/10

rucks-
solid. but if for kreuser to be a keeper as ur second ruck and value for money, he would need to average at least 85. however for about 50k cheaper, i think mcintosh is a better option and should average about the same as kreuser.

8.6/10

forwards-
great. cant rly fault it, maybe apart from milera. i think he will be fighting for a spot against saad. so u might want to pick one out of them

9/10

86 out of 100

[Jalapeno]

Thanks mate.. Really appreciated :-)  I have traded hanley for adcock. Also I like shuey this years and think he will be up around the 100 mark. Than ks for the ruck advice and I think I will traded kruze for h mac :-)