Post ur team, and I will give feedback and rate it out of 100

[Jalapeno]

Also after them trades I have 104k left :-)

[Chelskiman]

Adcock killed me last year.  Never again.  Hanley is a risk, but he could push his average up to 90 wuite easily I think.  I jumped of Shuey and went for Barlow, but something tells me Shuey will have a great year.  I have around $183k left.

[Optima]

Backs: Carrazzo, Enright, Shaw, Suckling, Waters, Clarke, Morris; Mulligan, Wilkes
Mids: Pendlebury, Ablett, Rockliff, Selwood, Pfeiffer, Shiel; Zorko, Miles
Rucks: Luenberger, Mumford; Giles, Stephensen
Forwards: Franklin, Goodes, Martin, Sidebottom, Cameron, Treloar, Lamb; Smedts, Kerridge

[owenbond007]

Cheers thanks for your opinion. Surprised you rated my backs higher. And I am in 2 minds over watto and swallow both have a lot of upside

[oc16]

Jemi

Backs-
Good. however i think having grimes aswell as waters is a bit risky, but if u think that they can both get back to their best then go for it. otherwise as i have said in previous posts, get heppell, by saving money elsewhere. also those rookies are ok, but there are better options, like ellis and mohr whom will defs be in their respective teams starting 22 come round 1.

8/10

Mids-
Very unorthodox. for the most part u only want to pick uniques if u think they will be mainstream in 2013. and chapman wont be, at least not in the midfield. ur better off having him down forward and that frees up space for a mid such as pendles or ablett, coz u should rly have at least 2 of either pendles, swan, or ablett to start with. also i think there are better options then simpson at his price, have a look at van berlo, from memory he didnt score under 100 after their new coach came in. or even sloane who also plays for adel, i think hes a good chance to explode this year.

7.5/10

Rucks-
Nothing wrong there

9.5/10

Forwards-
Put chapman in instead of riewoldt. and also choose either 1 or 2 players out of Christensen, Brown, and Winderlich. and instead put in rookies, have a look at saad (stk), walsh (syd), and cameron (gws). these guys are looking like they could get some early games. also i have some inside knowledge that bucks is gonna play beams mostly on the half forward flank and forward pocket, while sidebottom is going to play mostly as a midfielder so u might want to think about swapping those two, but its ur choice :).

8/10

82 out of 100

[bombers!!!]

scotland, goddard, delidio, fisher, grimes, lake, clarke (morris, bugg)
pendlebury, abblett, cooney, hayes, coniglio, tyson (shiel, kavanagh)
Mcintosh, Kreuzer (giles, stephensen)
franklin, pavlich, martin, Nick Riewoldt, winderlich, porplyzia, folau/peitiffer (folau/peitiffer, zorko)
i have 121,600 left in the bank.. please help!

[BIGCOLSYLVIA]

Backs: Goddard, Shaw ,Deledio, Birchall, Clarke, Ellis B , Bugg (Emergencies) Docherty, Darley

Midfield: Ablett, Selwood,  Thomas,  Barlow,  Pfieffer,  Tyson (Emergencies) Shiel, Brown

Rucks: Mumford,  Jacobs  (Emergencies) Giles, Stephenson

Fowards: Franklin,  Zaka,  Martin,  Fyfe,  Rooey,  Zorko,  Treloar  (Emergencies) Walsh,  Sexton


With 32,300 in the bank, i feel like my team is shaping up

[jemi]

Thanks mate: you're a big help.

[Junkitup]

Backs - S Burgoyne, B Waters, J Grimes, J Drummond, B Lake, M Clarke, T Mohr       
           Emg: P Faulks, J Bootsma

Mids - J Selwood, S Thompson, J Watson, A Goodes, M Barlow, L Hayes                   
          Emg: D Pfeiffer, L Brown

Rucks - A Sandilands, N Naitanui
          Emg: J Giles, O Stephenson

Fwds - L Franklin, D Martin, M Clark, J Brown, J Winderlich, J Porplyzia, S Byrnes
          Emg : D Zorko, J Cameron

$71,300 remaining

[Phasir]

DEF: Goddard, Deledio, Heppell, Yarran, Clarke, Smedts, Brown, (Mohr, Hine)
MID: Pendlebury, Ablett, Rockliff, Gibbs, Barlow, Shiel, (Miles, Gibson)
RUCK: Mumford, McIntosh, (Giles, Stephensen)
FWD: Franklin, Beams, Martin, Sidebottom, Brown, Zorko, Walsh, (Treloar, Panos)
Cash Left Over - $14,400

[bernie]

Backs
1. Goddard, B
2. Deledio, B
3. Adcock, J
4. Conca, R
5. Lake, B
6. Ellis, B
7. Mohr, T
23. Sierakowski, W
24. Morris, S
Midfield   
8. Ablett, G
9. Montagna, L
10. Hayes, L
11. Kerr, D
12. Coniglio, S   
13. Tyson, D   
25. Hampton, C
26. Shiel, D
Rucks
14. Cox, D   
15. Sandilands, A   
27. Giles, J
28. Stephensen, O

Forwards
16. Franklin, L
17. Goodes, A
18. Harvey, B
19. Riewoldt, N
20. Brown, J
21. Haynes, N
22. Rowe, S
29. Pfeiffer, D
30. Zorko, D
first team made this year got 248,000 left in the bank

[r-lawson-h]

Need a bit of advice i think, but how is this for a first attempt?


Back: Scotland, Deledio, Suckling, Pittard, Nicholson, Clarke, Frost (Spurr, Laird)

Mid: Swan, Thompson, Zaharakis, Shuey, Hayes, Coniglio (Horsley, Shiel)

Ruck: Goldstein, Leuenberger (Giles, Stephenson)

For: Beams, Okeefe, Martin, Fasolo, Winderlich, Pfeiffer, Zorko (Treloar, Kennedy)

$32,800

Thanks!  :)

[oc16]

just clancy

backline-
only thing is i think connors wont get many games early due to the fact he is just coming back from his second club suspension, u would be better off getting another tiger in ellis who will defs play round 1 and is rookie priced.

9/10

mids-
one of the better mids ive seen so far
9.3/10

rucks-
nothing wrong here. however ive got the same ruckline, and lots of other people seem to, so i was thinking for my team about maybe going with mcevoy instead, to be different. and he should still average about the same. coz the way i see it its out of either him and the berger for the second ruck position, if ur going to start with two premium rucks.

9.5/10

forwards-
good. however, i think u could improve it by getting rid of 1 or 2 of either brown, porpz or brynes, and instead trading one of them to someone like rowe, pfeiffer or walsh. and then upgrading one of them to someone like sidebottom or robinson.

8.7/10

91 out of 100

[oc16]

optima

backs-
Wheres goddard? if u want to go unique then u rly should have at least god. im not sure how much money u have left but try and trade suckling for goddard, ive heard that he could be given a roll change for 2012 and will be playing more on the wing, this means that unfortunately i dont think he will average as much as last year. everything else seems fine.

8.8/10

mids-
very nice, 2 rookie dp forwards which will mean u will have no trouble in covering players been dropped and being injured.

9.3/10

rucks-
a bit different, but should still be very competitive.

9.2/10

forwards-
im liking the look of that, very nice. kerridge has the potential to be a nice unique rookie.

9.3

92 out of 100

[howie24]

first go at my team for the season

back - Goddard, Shaw, Deledio, Waters, Grimes, Ellis, Mohr (Smedts, Morris)

mid - Swan, Murphy, Watson, hayes, Conigilio, Pfeiffer (Hampton, Brown)

ruck - Leuenberger, Mcintosh (Giles, Stephenson)

forward - Franklin, goodes, Fyfe, Cloke, Martin, Zorko, Treloar (Walsh, Rowe)