Help! Not sure on which option!

[JamSainter]

Is Grimes and Waters too much of a risk to have in the same team... and isn't Shaw coming off hip surgery. Just a bit confused at the moment  :P

[bjrouse]

IMO yes it is, especially in the same line.
I'd go Shaw and Rookie

[ando_10]

shaw and steven morris from richmond apparently pretty certain for round 1

[JamSainter]

Haha yeah Morris is already on my bench, he'll be a gun.

[ben_020285]

What's the rest of your backline look like? Can't really pass judgement without knowing that.

[JamSainter]

Fair enough.
Goddard, Deledio, Heppell, Grimes, Waters, Clarke, Mohr (Wilkes, Morris)

[ben_020285]

Goddard, Deledio, Heppell = Good.

I wouldn't go the Grimes, Waters option. Too much risk involved.

I think that out of your options you need H Shaw and I think the other player who needs to be there is Lake. If he stinks it up during NAB cup then scrap him but he is an absolute bargain at 287k.

Maybe discard Clarke and free up some cash in another line to bring Lake in. That's my thoughts.

[JamSainter]

I agree, I am not sold on Lake... I will make room for him but as you said I can always remove him if he has a bad NAB Cup. But with Lake, there is a lot of risk aswell but I guess he is 100K cheaper!