Would Conca be a better option than Shaw?!?!?

[mdub]

Thinking about shaw on his past seasons he hasnt made the brightesst decisions. So could it be a unique option to go with conca, as he is has good chances of playing in the midfield.

[Cicjose]

im expecting people to take a serious look at all the richmond backmen this year

there are some gems in there its just about picking the right ones

[Kuruki]

It kinda depends on your team structure and what you will do with that extra money if you went Conca. Shaw will score more no doubt about it and he will be a keeper. Im hoping Conca will score well enough to be my 7th back keeper.
You dont want to miss the boat on Conca, so maybe sitting back and watching Shaw as an upgrade target might be a better option.

[sliced ham]

yeah i dunno about conca if your not hoping for him to be a keeper then he is just an expensive cash cow and personally i would rather go the rookie and there are plenty of them

[Cruiseon]

As an aside Head to Head in a dark angry alley, who'd walk out the victor between those two?

[picker_man]

As an aside Head to Head in a dark angry alley, who'd walk out the victor between those two?

Ill put 10bucks on shaw :P

[sliced ham]

As an aside Head to Head in a dark angry alley, who'd walk out the victor between those two?

hmm i feel like shaw has the experience, hes done some dodgy shower in his day, cant imagine what he hasnt been caught for. but i feel conca has youth on his side. conca has the height advantage but shaw the weight. all in all i would be putting my money on shaw.

[Kuruki]

As an aside Head to Head in a dark angry alley, who'd walk out the victor between those two?

hmm i feel like shaw has the experience, hes done some dodgy shower in his day, cant imagine what he hasnt been caught for. but i feel conca has youth on his side. conca has the height advantage but shaw the weight. all in all i would be putting my money on shaw.

Id put mine on Conca. You can guarantee someone from DT will walk past and say "Oh shyt thats the spuddy flower Shaw that shafted me last year" they will crack him over the head with a bottle and Conca will win.

[Cicjose]

As an aside Head to Head in a dark angry alley, who'd walk out the victor between those two?

hmm i feel like shaw has the experience, hes done some dodgy shower in his day, cant imagine what he hasnt been caught for. but i feel conca has youth on his side. conca has the height advantage but shaw the weight. all in all i would be putting my money on shaw.

Id put mine on Conca. You can guarantee someone from DT will walk past and say "Oh shyt thats the spuddy flower that shafted me last year" they will crack him over the head with a bottle and Conca will win.

haha gold 8)

[Windigo]

Not getting Shaw full stop.

Only 2 Pies I'll be considering are Swan & Beams/Cloke.

[Football Factory]

As an aside Head to Head in a dark angry alley, who'd walk out the victor between those two?

Ill put 10bucks on shaw :P

+ 1  ;D

[Colliwobblers]

be as mad at Shaw as you like and be as optimistic on conca as you like, fact is saw will outscore him by minimum 10, because i have conca as a keeper 7th defender and expect 80-90 out of him, Shaw should average 95. upgrade target for me if he behaves.

[picker_man]

i was about to have a big rant about y all the hype around conca, he cant ave anywere 90 ect ect but just did a bit of research and at 270k i think he's now a good a risk as any even though unproven, yet to hit the 100 in any game and coming into his 2nd yr thers quite a bit of upside to the guy. dont know if ill pick him but wont have my rant about him :-X haha

[Ziplock]

I don't buy into the conca hype.

[GoldDigger]

A rare bird, the good second year investment.