took some advice hows it look now? 2012 sc team

[Malakia]

Hi guys
just wanna get a few thoughts on this team, got a fair bit of cash left so im trying to decide where to spend it.
cheers

My Planned Super Coach Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by Malakia. Salary cap left: $151,100.

Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Matt Suckling, Dyson Heppell, Reece Conca, Marty Clarke, Tim Mohr
Billie Smedts, Luke Brown

Gary Ablett jnr, Dane Swan, Scott Thompson, Michael Barlow, Kyal Horsely, Dylan Shiel
James McDonald, Tom Mitchell

Aaron Sandilands, Hamish McIntosh
Sam Rowe, Orren Stephenson

Lance Franklin, Dayne Beams, Dustin Martin, Jonathan Brown, Allen Christensen, Ahmed Saad, Tommy Walsh
Dayne Zorko, Adam Treloar

[ossie85]

HMac as 2nd ruck is risky! Not sure I'd go for, but I think the reason you're not getting many comments is because it is a pretty well balanced side

[meow meow]

Saad will score poorly. The most possessions he has ever gotten in a VFL match is 15. In some matches he kicked 4 goals but only had 5 kicks. I can't see him getting too many 5 goal bags in AFL.

I seem to be in the minority, but I don't see Conca in Richmond's best 22.

Thompson is a nice unique. Mitchell is in the rehab group still so could be a downgrade target instead.

Spend the extra coin and get a better 2nd ruck.

[Malakia]

cheers guys,

Have done a few changes as suggested,atm ill leave conca in and see how he goes nab cup wise. alot of people seem to be mentioning suban and grimes for good and bad reasons so ill keep an eye on them.
with macintosh no one else is really exciting me tried to free up some cash but was just short on getting berger and the few under him im not sold on. Jacobs is in for now was impressed with him last year(howeva i am a crows fan) and his bye matches macintoshs
here is the team with the changes

My Planned Super Coach Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by Malakia. Salary cap left: $30,800.

Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Matt Suckling, Dyson Heppell, Reece Conca, Marty Clarke, Tim Mohr
Billie Smedts, Luke Brown

Gary Ablett jnr, Dane Swan, Scott Thompson, Michael Barlow, Kyal Horsely, Dylan Shiel
Sam Kerridge, James McDonald

Aaron Sandilands, Sam Jacobs
Sam Rowe, Orren Stephenson

Lance Franklin, Dayne Beams, Dustin Martin, Jonathan Brown, Allen Christensen, Adam Treloar, Tommy Walsh
Dayne Zorko, Alex Sexton

[Colliwobblers]

cheers guys,
Have done a few changes as suggested,atm ill leave conca in and see how he goes nab cup wise. alot of people seem to be mentioning suban and grimes for good and bad reasons so ill keep an eye on them.
with macintosh no one else is really exciting me tried to free up some cash but was just short on getting berger and the few under him im not sold on. Jacobs is in for now was impressed with him last year(howeva i am a crows fan) and his bye matches macintoshs
here is the team with the changes
My Planned Super Coach Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by Malakia. Salary cap left: $30,800.
Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Matt Suckling, Dyson Heppell, Reece Conca, Marty Clarke, Tim Mohr
Billie Smedts, Luke Brown
Gary Ablett jnr, Dane Swan, Scott Thompson, Michael Barlow, Kyal Horsely, Dylan Shiel
Sam Kerridge, James McDonald
Aaron Sandilands, Sam Jacobs
Sam Rowe, Orren Stephenson
Lance Franklin, Dayne Beams, Dustin Martin, Jonathan Brown, Allen Christensen, Adam Treloar, Tommy Walsh
Dayne Zorko, Alex Sexton

DEF: great love conca strong premiums and rooks
MID: Solid great choices, horseley needs to be promoted off the rookie list and make sure kerrige looks like a starter early
RUCK: solid.
FWD: very strong, brown and christo should both havve great years, again good premo's good rooks.

Overall a very strong side well balanced no weak lines like it a lot. GL

[theflyinghawk]

one of the best ones ive seen for sure

[Malakia]

one of the best ones ive seen for sure

Ha ha cheers hawk, and the rest for giving your opinions I've got a few players I wouldn't normally have so just wanted to float them past everyone see how it all lined up. And wobbles cheers for the info on horsley didn't know he was a rookie but with kerridge he's a big bodied mid so hopefully that's wat sando wants and he gets a run otherwise I've got a bit of cash left so I'll change him over before it actually starts

[PICCOLLO]

I agree, very strong.  If ur midpricers perform, its a top 1000 team for sure.

[RHC123]

Yep agree with most in this thread. You are relying on Brown/Christensen/Conca etc to be bargains, but I don't see why they won't be so it's all good.

1 thing about rookies, not entirely sure on James McDonald?? He's at GWS more for a leadership/coaching role off the field I'm pretty sure, so may not play a lot of games?

But it looks a very good team