Broughton vs Waters

[mmurphy3]

Which one

[Raiden]

Broughton, hopefully he get's more time in the Mid this year, however not sure what Ross Lyon's plans will be.

[pavs nose]

They've already decided on more midfield time for ballantyne so i doubt broughton will get any more. they are wanting to add speed

[Football Factory]

On overall scoring potential id say Broughton......aslong as structure or price has nothing to do with it   :P

[Ziplock]

waters 90+

you heard it from me :P

[Football Factory]

waters 90+

you heard it from me :P

Waters 90 points per game ..10 games for the season lol = 900 so yes i think Broughton will score more points "overall"   :P

[valkorum]

Not sure that Broughton will get more midfield time.  Not with Mundy, Mora, Barlow all coming back - Broughton was a last gasp fill during the middle of the 2011 season

[DT Gun]

people have severely over rated morabito, and the impact he is going to have next year

[valkorum]

people have severely over rated morabito, and the impact he is going to have next year

I never over rated him just letting people know that he will be back (and in the midfield), meaning less room for Broughton in the midfield.  Never said Mora was the 2nd coming of Jesus, although lots of this would nice

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ev08PeGME84&feature=related

check out the Sandi shepherd - although Darcy calls him Franklin but Walls corrects him ;)

[DT Gun]

that was before he injured his knee

[valkorum]

that was before he injured his knee

So returning from a knee injury stops him from being a good player?  I am saying that I am not sure that Broughton's role will be in the midfield, not with the likes of Barlow, Mundy and Morabito returning.

[pavs nose]

I think he will play on a wing and kick a fair few running goals. don't forget moabito was compared with adam goods prior to being drafted. leave him out at your peril....

[Off Tap]

I think he will play on a wing and kick a fair few running goals. don't forget moabito was compared with adam goods prior to being drafted. leave him out at your peril....

Or pick him and be disappointed. There's better value than him running around in 2012.

[Colliwobblers]

the only thing that destroyed broughtons DT 2011 was his imbosile coach, if broughton is let loose again in the midfield or at least free to rebound off HB and not play a lock down role which is a total waste of his talents IMO, he will average 100+ just like he did mid season 2011 in that free running role.

Hopefuly he gets to show us his role in nab cup and if he is touted as a mid/HB running defender rebounding DT whore stud love machine he is locked in my team.

Waters isnt bad either but not in broughtons league imo.