Daisy Thomas vs Joel Selwood

[mmurphy3]

Which one?

[Colliwobblers]

Men call me Mick malty house because I have a soft spot for daisy but he simply isn't jelwood level yet, maybe he will take a big leap forward this season maybe next but until he does my vote goes to jelwood.

[nichsa673]

Joel Selwood is an absoloute gun, who consistently scores. He is a proven scorer. daisy is also a proven scorer, but is not as proven and smoetimes inconsistent. Selwood is definetly the better option.

[Football Factory]

Selwood

[jballstars]

not even close Selwood

[Ziplock]

yeah, selwood clear cut.

[SCAddict]

Selwood by a country mile

[Raiden]

Selwood.

[DT Gun]

if you had to ask, i think your gonna struggle selecting your side

[Ziplock]

did people just select thomas for lols :S

[Holz]

did people just select thomas for lols :S

they could possibly be super biased collingwood supporters.


Is anyone worried that when gellong eventually decline selwood will strugle to score 110+ or is he that much of a gun he will keep improving to a 115+ average.

Im going of topic as there is really no question.

[nichsa673]

you see a lot of players still getting big scores when they are not in great teams. even though  think geelong will be good for a few years still, player like rockliff, boyd  watson are all able to get big scores. and st kilda went backwards this year, and we saw NDS score go up.

[Ziplock]

you see a lot of players still getting big scores when they are not in great teams. even though  think geelong will be good for a few years still, player like rockliff, boyd  watson are all able to get big scores. and st kilda went backwards this year, and we saw NDS score go up.

common misconception. Unless you call a 0.6 average rise going up, even though it was lower than his 09 average (marginally)

[nichsa673]

my point is the teams performance doesnt necessarily mean player performance decrease.

[Holz]

you see a lot of players still getting big scores when they are not in great teams. even though  think geelong will be good for a few years still, player like rockliff, boyd  watson are all able to get big scores. and st kilda went backwards this year, and we saw NDS score go up.

common misconception. Unless you call a 0.6 average rise going up, even though it was lower than his 09 average (marginally)

i agree we also saw tags, goddard and nroo go down on average after being premiums in each postion.