Your best bargain midfield rookie prospects!

Started by elephants, January 10, 2012, 04:51:14 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which are the four best options for the midfield strategy below??

Tom Mitchell
22 (157.1%)
Stephen Clifton
16 (114.3%)
Dylan Shiel
34 (242.9%)
James McDonald
25 (178.6%)
Kyal Horsely
19 (135.7%)
Anothony Miles
6 (42.9%)
Koby Stevens
13 (92.9%)
Sebastian Ross
1 (7.1%)
Clay Smith
4 (28.6%)
Elliot Kavagnah
11 (78.6%)

Total Members Voted: 14

elephants

Pretty much I, like many, are running with 4 midfield guns and 4 midfield rookies. For those who are more visual learners its something like this...

gun, gun, gun, gun, rookie, rookie
(rookie, rookie)

My question is who are the best cheaper midfield rookies.
If you want someone added to the poll I'll do so.

Note that these are your cheaper midfield rookies so guys like Wingard and Coniglio are NOT options. Also keep in mind I am not after mpp rookies as I'm after the best money makers not the best flexibility tactics.

Thanks all.

dswallow24

Well for me , and for now i have chosen

Stephen Coniglio
Stephen Clifton
Dylan Shiel
Koby Stevens

I can say Dylan Shiel is a lock for me, unless injury or something happens

kilbluff1985

Well for me a dark horse this year will be Josh Caddy would have been in most sides last year but he got injured

Windigo

What do you mean by "Gun." Not 4, 450K+ players?

Matty411

Mitchell, MacDonald and Clifton are practically locked for me - the last spot will be out of Docherty (DPP link), Sheil, Miles, Stevens and Horsley depending on NAB form and rnd 1 lists.

Windigo


scotty_222

caddy is like 250k
would have been a lock if he was still on rookie prices

kilbluff1985

#7
Caddy is only 218k not much more then Coniglio

Other then that i would say Kavagnah, Essendon need another inside mid ball winner and they know it so he should get games if he shows form in pre season


Football Factory

D.Pfeiffer. Round 13 bye

Darren Pfeiffer ..M/F if he gets elevated. Has the added advantage of Port Adelaide only having captain Domenic Cassisi on the veterans list meaning they can elevate a rookie before the start of the season.

Peter Rohde ( Port Adelaide general manager of football ) says " We see him as a flexible player. He can play in alot of spots. He can certainly play in the midfield and off half-back and he's mature and ready to go. "

http://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/6038/newsid/127096/default.aspx

http://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/ptv/tabid/11037/contentid/409094/default.aspx

scotty_222

Quote from: kilbluff1995 on January 10, 2012, 11:54:00 AM
Caddy is only 218k not much more then Coniglio

Other then that i would say Kavagnah, Essendon need another inside mid ball winner and they know it so he should get games if he shows form in pre season


thats a bit for a rookie dont you think?
you would probably get 2 rookies for that price that will probably avg the same

elephants

Quote from: Windigo on January 10, 2012, 10:47:50 AM
What do you mean by "Gun." Not 4, 450K+ players?
Well I mean threw 450k plus players and Barlow as my guns.
Thanks for the feedback so far Lads.

chatters24

The Kav will be a good one I think. He'll definetly get games too!

Football Factory

Quote from: kilbluff1995 on January 10, 2012, 11:54:00 AM
Caddy is only 218k not much more then Coniglio

Other then that i would say Kavagnah, Essendon need another inside mid ball winner and they know it so he should get games if he shows form in pre season
In the fanplanner Caddy is priced at 249k is this a mistake ?

elephants

Quote from: Miss Pies on January 10, 2012, 06:25:48 PM
I only rate Mitchell and Smith.
I have played against Mitchell, that's my claim to fame.

Holz

shiel and mitchell are almost locks in my team will have to do something wrong to not start in my team,

if kavanagh is named round 1 i will pick him and i would suggest others do to, im seeing alot of simularaties with heppel in him ( despite being a mid only)

for the lqast rookie spot im deciding to go for wingard who i really like or wait for the nab to find the 4th rookie, but at this stage im

Wingard, Mitchell starting with shiel and kavanagah on the bench