Team Draft #3 NEW

Started by Jamesy, January 09, 2012, 02:48:40 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

prozz710

Nice base, but i think it needs a bit of work;
Backs: Nice group of scorers, everyone knows Grimes is a risk but can be a great scorer if he stays fit, and im really happy with the look of Clarke, should slot into the team and bring in some solid scores, for a a deep back option.

Mids: Mids look nice, with Gaj, Selly and Goodes, you have a nice spread of rookies and DPP which is very useful

Rucks: You have saved a lot of money here which would have been very beneficial to you around the ground, Cox is a great ruckman, not sure if he'll perform as well this year as he did last, but still a good choice,  id probably start Giles over Longer, as Longer is playing behind Leuenberger

FWDS: Your forwards require a lot of luck, depending on whether Brown and Porpoise can stay on the park and i feel as a tigers supporter that Martin is a risk, one worth taking but a risk none the less

Pretty Good team, havent really looked at the byes yet so cant give you a real insight on that, just be careful with your backline, with 3 tigers, especiallyy with your 2 bench players, you could get caught if the other backman have byes in the same round

PICCOLLO

Goodes is notorious for slow starts to season and is normally a bargain during the year - dont start with him.
Heath scotland is a terrific player but can he back up a career best last year at his age?
The Rest is good.  Keep in mind you have grimes, lake, brown and porps all coming off significant injuries.

Jamesy

Backline:
B Goddard, H Scotland, B Deledio,                       B Ellis
J Grimes, B Lake, M Clarke, A Tomlinson               S Morris

Midfield:
G Ablett, J Selwood, A Goodes,                            J Mcdonald
M Barlow, K Stevens, D Zorko                                 L Brown

Ruck: 
D Cox, J Giles                                                   S Rowe
                                                                     O Stephenson 

Forward:
L Franklin, N Fyfe, D Martin                                B Smedts
D Zaharakis, J Brown, J Porplyza, D Pfeiffer           A Saad


And Goodes will likely stay in my side at Midfield as he has a good draw to start the season, and also he is the only other Midfield/Forward that i think can have the role of a 3Mid. Also I will move around the backline to get rid of one of the 2 Tiger defenders but i just don't know who i'd drop and who i'd pick up yet with our lack of knowledge on the rookies. I've decided to drop Longer and pick up Rowe from the comments made by the Blues saying he is a likely player to make the 22 and that made room to upgrade for Koby Stevens in the Mid, but adjustments will be made still, I am looking at Consiglio still and would enjoy his presence in my side.

Impromptu

#18
Quote from: Jamesy on January 15, 2012, 07:17:17 PM
New edit for the team, please leave some constructive feedback that i can use.
Whether this team would work with the bye weeks and whether or not there is better plyers i could use in different positions, etc


Backline:
B Goddard, H Scotland, B Deledio,                       B Ellis
J Grimes, B Lake, M Clarke, A Tomlinson               S Morris

Midfield:
G Ablett, J Selwood, A Goodes,                            J Mcdonald
M Barlow, D Shiel, D Zorko                                 L Brown

Ruck: 
D Cox, B Longer                                               J Giles
                                                                     O Stephenson 

Forward:
L Franklin, N Fyfe, D Martin                                B Smedts
D Zaharakis, J Brown, J Porplyza, D Pfeiffer           A Treloar

Salary remaining: $11,800

Longer definitely no, rather pay the extra bucks and get Renouf.  Longer is behind Luenberger and Hudson and priced at 160k iirc

Nothing wrong with J.Brown but rather pay a bit of a surcharge and get N.Roo....Might want to get Cameron(GWS) into the forwardline as I hear he is good (watch nab cup).  Note Pfeiffer is on the rookie list (iirc) list so make sure he is elevated. Horsley (GC) is a lock if he is elevated from rookie list. A bit of a gamble with lake and grimes but nothing wrong with them per se