5th Defender

Started by R.Griffen, December 31, 2011, 12:44:49 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who to pick as my 5th Defender

Beau Waters
6 (35.3%)
Jack Grimes
6 (35.3%)
Brian Lake
3 (17.6%)
Other
2 (11.8%)

Total Members Voted: 1

R.Griffen

I can buy anyone under B.Waters

elephants

Considered Armstrong? My 5th back is a rookieand i've spent the dough elsewhere for you though... of those player listed i would go waters.

R.Griffen

Quote from: elephants on December 31, 2011, 01:00:22 PM
Considered Armstrong? My 5th back is a rookieand i've spent the dough elsewhere for you though... of those player listed i would go waters.

If Armstrong didn't get traded I would have picked him I am just not sure about his role at Sydney

elephants


kilbluff1985

Would just go for a rookie myself

elephants


R.Griffen

Quote from: elephants on December 31, 2011, 01:20:11 PM
Quote from: kilbluff1995 on December 31, 2011, 01:17:22 PM
Would just go for a rookie myself
Yeah my initial reaction.

I have $723,000 and I need my number 1 ruck and my 5th Defender

Kuruki

What about Phil Davis. He doesn't seem to be a popular option, there will be tons of pill down back for GWS. Is there a reason why not many have mentioned him??.

Fyfe_gun

My 5th defender is Dyson Heppell but for your price you could look at Dempsey, Yarran, Waters and Grimes all good options

R.Griffen

Quote from: Kuruki on December 31, 2011, 01:24:15 PM
What about Phil Davis. He doesn't seem to be a popular option, there will be tons of pill down back for GWS. Is there a reason why not many have mentioned him??.

He is a big key defender not a Dream Team player

Fyfe_gun

Quote from: Kuruki on December 31, 2011, 01:24:15 PM
What about Phil Davis. He doesn't seem to be a popular option, there will be tons of pill down back for GWS. Is there a reason why not many have mentioned him??.

Yeah because initially it was thought he would be rookie priced but he is expensive for his past and has shown he has injury problems

Zac Dawson at freo could also be interesting?

R.Griffen

Quote from: Fyfe_gun on December 31, 2011, 01:27:24 PM
Quote from: Kuruki on December 31, 2011, 01:24:15 PM
What about Phil Davis. He doesn't seem to be a popular option, there will be tons of pill down back for GWS. Is there a reason why not many have mentioned him??.

Yeah because initially it was thought he would be rookie priced but he is expensive for his past and has shown he has injury problems

Zac Dawson at freo could also be interesting?

Zac Dawson is very lucky to be playing AFL he is so bad biggest Spud of all time

owenbond007

Id go waters. Top player can get the decent size tons too. I wouldnt say never ever but grimes is a DT bad seed a lot more of a risk i think.

jamster

richard tambling anyone, named as a defender?

ronl

The new Bulldog coach is a pretty tough nut, if he didn't think Lake had another solid year left in him, I think he would have sent him packing.  I'm sticking with him.  Also impressed by Yarran's year.  No-one seems to mention him much, maybe not enough upside.