Barlow/Hayes/Sloane

[theflyinghawk]

Which one would you choose?

[elephants]

I have Barlow but i'll say Sloane for uniqueness and an easy draw.

[popedelio]

Barlow because we know what his scoring potential is. He is definitely the safest option, and the most obvious if he is fit

[Doyle]

If you want a trusted scorer, take Hayes. If you want a very unique player, get Sloane and if you want an outright DT gun get Barlow

[Phasir]

Hayes is a top bloke & also a form super-premo of his time, but he's gettin' on in his career & might not get back to his best after a pretty bad injury.

Barlow came into the AFL and killed it, we all know that. expect +100 avg. in 2012, but he might miss 4 or 5 matches from soreness.. you don't break a leg like he did & recover to top fitness in a year.

Sloane probably won't ever be a DT gun, unlike the other two he's not a dominant player, maybe in a few years but pass for now.

[Ziplock]

no, you certainly don't. But in like 20 months? I think he might be close to fully recovered.

[Torpedo10]

Sloane and If I could pick two they would be Sloane and Barlow.

[Holz]

Its easy to see the odd one out of the 3, for me barlow is a lokc and im taking hayes to, wouldnt even think about sloane

[Phasir]

I said you could still expect high scores from him & that he'll probably play around 17-18 matches which is fine, just saying he'll probably be more likely to be rested from soreness than some other players.

[Fyfe_gun]

Barlow is a lock. Sloane is more of a supercoach player. He is a gun onfield but that doesnt always equal dt points

[Doyle]

Barlow is a lock. Sloane is more of a supercoach player. He is a gun onfield but that doesnt always equal dt points

Nice analysis, I agree  ;)

[azza707]

sloane could be a good pick, its just very hard to call. has stacked on 4 kilos already to date and sanderson said is training the best out of the group. watch pre season carefully but i think he might still be just one season away from really stepping up to that elite level.