2012 EXV Rounds

[meow meow]

I think it is pretty unfair that Torp scored more but lost the match. I don't make the rules though.

[nostradamus]

I think it is pretty unfair that Torp scored more but lost the match. I don't make the rules though.

l agree totally, but in saying that l'm not having a go at Holz

[Holz]

I think it is pretty unfair that Torp scored more but lost the match. I don't make the rules though.

l agree totally, but in saying that l'm not having a go at Holz

see this is where im in trouble, the rules say that Meow go through. because i didn't really think about this happening and I should have.

this rule I have been using all season for the draws. because I felt a loss by a few points in a comp where you score around 1300 was unfair.

[PowerBug]

I was the higher ranked team last week, but torp scored more, I should've gone through. :P



Rules are rules, and i agree with Holzman. :)

[Torpedo10]

I think it is pretty unfair that Torp scored more but lost the match. I don't make the rules though.

This is why I am so frusterated about this. I guess I have to accept it. Holzman is the rule maker and if he makes a decision that even the opposition team's coach who goes into the GF with this decision knows it's unfair I guess I have to accept it.

[Justin Bieber]

Then we shouldn't have draw during the home and away if we went on the exact points...

[Holz]

Then we shouldn't have draw during the home and away if we went on the exact points...

I will look into this for next season it appears people are unhappy with this rule. I has been used for the 4th time this season and will need to reflect on it for next season.

What are peoples feelings on the draws in the home and away season?

I may change both to exact points or just the finals to exact points depending on opinions.

[Torpedo10]

Then we shouldn't have draw during the home and away if we went on the exact points...

I will look into this for next season it appears people are unhappy with this rule. I has been used for the 4th time this season and will need to reflect on it for next season.

What are peoples feelings on the draws in the home and away season?

I may change both to exact points or just the finals to exact points depending on opinions.

My thoughts would be to not have them at all unless it's a perfect draw(same fantasy points). Then it goes who is ranked higher in finals if THEY ARE EXACTLY THE SAME SCORE IN DREAMTEAM POINTS.I hate how I've suffered the consequences of no rule made for this situation but if it never happens again atleast no one will feel how I fell at the moment.

[meow meow]

Give Torp the win. He scored more so he deserves to win.

[Justin Bieber]

Torp if draw didn't go like this I would of beaten ele and passed you on the ladder...

[Torpedo10]

Torp if draw didn't go like this I would of beaten ele and passed you on the ladder...

If draw hadn't gone like this I would have beaten LH and sustained my 8th spot on the ladder.

[elephants]

Torp if draw didn't go like this I would of beaten ele and passed you on the ladder...

Not even ;)

[Scrads]

How about we pretend I played Torp and Nos played Meow this week and they both lose and get knocked out and I play Nos in the final :P

I reckon Holz made a fair ruling, he has stuck with the rule that was used during the season. If there is anything you have to do in the rules of this comp it is be consistent because that is only fair.

[Torpedo10]

How about we pretend I played Torp and Nos played Meow this week and they both lose and get knocked out and I play Nos in the final :P

I reckon Holz made a fair ruling, he has stuck with the rule that was used during the season. If there is anything you have to do in the rules of this comp it is be consistent because that is only fair.

This rule works a little for finals but still it's unfair if someone clearly tops another (more than 1 point) and it gets 'rounded' back so it's a draw and THEN the team who was higher ranked wins is totally unfair.

[Justin Bieber]

Yeah to be honest Torp should probably win...