Main Menu

Australia v India v Sri Lanka

Started by Master Q, December 12, 2011, 06:54:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

DT Gun

You guys are too harsh on Cicjose.

you cant say his opinions may or may not be right, why do you think we have a selection panel?

Everyone is going to have a different opinion, with no correct answer. Thats why they hire a team of guys to collectively vote on a side. Are you guys telling me you have agreed with every single selection in Australian Cricket history? No, you haven't.

There will always be merit in dropping and swapping every single player, either if its form, player management, giving players time to spend with families etc..

Hate reading you guys who think there is only 1 right answer in terms of selection, cos there is never a right answer!



roo boys!

STARCY :D :D

Although it's a shame because I decided not to trade him in the Fantasy Big Bash :P :(

Maca24

In comes Harris IMO.

And I'll say it again, Tim Paine hurry up and get fit! I want to bash the hell out of Brad Haddin  >:(

Boomz

Quote from: DT Gun on January 07, 2012, 01:12:56 AM
You guys are too harsh on Cicjose.

you cant say his opinions may or may not be right, why do you think we have a selection panel?

Everyone is going to have a different opinion, with no correct answer. Thats why they hire a team of guys to collectively vote on a side. Are you guys telling me you have agreed with every single selection in Australian Cricket history? No, you haven't.

There will always be merit in dropping and swapping every single player, either if its form, player management, giving players time to spend with families etc..

Hate reading you guys who think there is only 1 right answer in terms of selection, cos there is never a right answer!

Hi Cic. Getting inspiration from Dyl?

Maca24

Can't be Cic boomz.

Cic talkz lik dis wif no puntution lyk 4 reel.  :P

Cicjose

Quote from: Boomz on January 07, 2012, 03:04:19 PM
Quote from: DT Gun on January 07, 2012, 01:12:56 AM
You guys are too harsh on Cicjose.

you cant say his opinions may or may not be right, why do you think we have a selection panel?

Everyone is going to have a different opinion, with no correct answer. Thats why they hire a team of guys to collectively vote on a side. Are you guys telling me you have agreed with every single selection in Australian Cricket history? No, you haven't.

There will always be merit in dropping and swapping every single player, either if its form, player management, giving players time to spend with families etc..

Hate reading you guys who think there is only 1 right answer in terms of selection, cos there is never a right answer!

Hi Cic. Getting inspiration from Dyl?

i dont resort to multiple accounts regardless of your stupidity

upthemaidens

Quote from: Maca24 on January 07, 2012, 03:01:38 PM
In comes Harris IMO.

And I'll say it again, Tim Paine hurry up and get fit! I want to bash the hell out of Brad Haddin  >:(
yeah haddin did not keep well that game.    im not tooooo fussed that he doesnt score runs all the time and can be hot and cold,,BUT  not keeping well there is no excuse, thats his job in the team.
 

roo boys!

I want Haddin to keep performing just until the Big Bash is over, then get Wade into the team! But not so that he misses any Stars games ;)

Maca24

Wades not even an option IMO.
If they wanted Wade they would have put him in. It's clear to me that they are leaving Haddin until Paine is fit.

Cicjose

Well the selectors will miss the boat then

upthemaidens

Quote from: Maca24 on January 07, 2012, 04:26:39 PM
Wades not even an option IMO.
If they wanted Wade they would have put him in. It's clear to me that they are leaving Haddin until Paine is fit.
yeah that seems the thinking,,  i dont think theres any change to atleast the end of the summer.
whats actually wrong with Paine? and how long is he out for?
  also any word on watson?

Hawka

Ive heard this from some ex cricketers on tv and radio and also a journo that the aussie want Paine. Though know wade is a talent but they dont want to give him a chance to cerment a spot before Paine
I think its stupid i want Paine in over Wade but give Wade a chance
Paine prob will miss the west indies tour in march

Cicjose

Paine has a broken finger not likely to come back this summer

Watson should be fit at the end of the series against India

upthemaidens

Quote from: hawka26 on January 07, 2012, 04:33:48 PM
Ive heard this from some ex cricketers on tv and radio and also a journo that the aussie want Paine. Though know wade is a talent but they dont want to give him a chance to cerment a spot before Paine
I think its stupid i want Paine in over Wade but give Wade a chance
Paine prob will miss the west indies tour in march
well that seems alittle silly, if paine is going to be out for an unknown amount of time. they need to bite the bullet and get the next in line into the team.,  i mean if wade is given a shot AND does well enough to cement his spot, then surely he deserves it

Master Q

Exactly. Give Wade a shot even though he is probably second to Paine.