rank in order

Started by starz, December 09, 2011, 07:11:09 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

starz

swan pendles gaz boyd rockliff murphy

for me it's

swan
gaz
pendles
boyd
rockliff
murphy

not sure though

Cicjose

swan
pendles
boyd
ablett
murphy
rockliff

Ziplock

for me,
Swan
Ablett
Pendles

are the clear top 3, in that order (that being said, ablett may challenge swanny this year)

then boyd
murphy
rockliff

I rate boyd above both those two, but murphy/ rocky can go either way.

Torpedo10

Swan
Ablett
Pendles
Rockliff
Boyd
Murphy

Holz

Quote from: Ziplock on December 09, 2011, 08:11:14 PM
for me,
Swan
Ablett
Pendles

are the clear top 3, in that order (that being said, ablett may challenge swanny this year)

then boyd
murphy
rockliff

I rate boyd above both those two, but murphy/ rocky can go either way.

Ablett
Swan
Pendles
Selwood ( i know not on the list)

Ziplock

I agree with holz, selwood should be up there as well.

mmmm, Ablett over swan is a big call. Average wise, I can see it as a 50/50, giving swan the edge since he's out performed in recent years. I would lock ablett for my dt first though.

bomberboy0618

Ablett
Pendles
Swan
Boyd
Murphy
Rockliff
Pendles has more potential for my mind, but Ablett is the son of God after all.

starz

Forgot about selwood probably put him before boud

Ziplock

next year I think I would rate selwood 4th, maybe even 3rd if he can edge out pendles :P

Holz

if we are talking top 6 mids i would think barlow or mundy could sneak in there depending on lyons plan

stew42

Swan
GAJ
Boyd
Pendles
Rockliff
Murphy
Of course, this is who I'd prefer in my DT, not actual playing skill!

Doyle

Swan
GAJ
Pendlebury

Boyd
Murphy
Rockliff

The last two were ranked the way they are based on that fact that Murphy has been playing for longer, but if Rockliff keeps up his DT domination then everything changes doesn't ;)

The guy you missed is Selwood. He would be above Murphy, Boyd and Rockliff. Maybe even Pendlebury, but probably not

DT Gun

In Real Life football I would say..

Ablett
Pendlebury
Selwood
Swan
Boyd
Murphy

In Dream Team
Swan
Ablett
Pendlebury/Selwood
Boyd
Rockliff/Murphy