2012: Old school vs New school mids

charliesheen · November 26, 2011, 04:14:16 PM

Who would come out on top?

S.Pendlebury, M.Murphy, J.Selwood, Rockliff, A.Swallow, D.Mundy

vs

D.Swan, C.Judd, G.Ablett, M.Boyd, M.Priddis, NDS

Voldemort · November 26, 2011, 04:17:47 PM

ooo, nice question

Swan and Pendlebury cancel out

Judd and Murphy just about cancel out

Ablett and Selwood cancel out (Or Ablett just wins that battle)

Rockliff beats Boyd

Priddis beats Swallow

NDS beats Mundy

Old School, but just ;)

ronl · November 26, 2011, 04:47:04 PM

Agree with Voldemort, only Boyd beats Rockliff.

My Chumps · November 26, 2011, 05:24:11 PM

Boyd evens Rockliff.
Swallow equal with Priddis.
NDS and Mundy a draw too.
Ablett beats Selwood.
Judd and Smurph a draw.
Pendles beats Swan.

Oldies 3
Youngens 3

TheMailman · November 26, 2011, 07:52:16 PM

Do you mean in terms of averages? one game? or total points for whole season?

IMO it makes a big difference depending on which one

Voldemort · November 26, 2011, 07:58:17 PM

Quote from: TheMailman on November 26, 2011, 07:52:16 PM
Do you mean in terms of averages? one game? or total points for whole season?

IMO it makes a big difference depending on which one

Generally speaking

Torress · November 27, 2011, 02:22:30 AM

swan vs ~~pendles~~
judd vs ~~murphy~~
ablett vs ~~selwood~~
boyd vs ~~rocklciff~~
~~priddis~~ vs swallow
NDS vs ~~mundy~~

its a 5-1 old school win for me with swallow over priddis

bomberboy0618 · November 27, 2011, 09:27:26 AM

Swan=Pendles
Judd>Murphy
Ablett>Selwood
Boyd<Rockliff
Priddis>Swallow
NDS=Murphy
3-1 old school win.
Nice question btw!

TheMailman · November 27, 2011, 10:17:18 AM

If you were referring to whole season points. Oldies would win

In most other situations I'd give it to the Young uns

RiOtChEsS · November 27, 2011, 11:50:35 AM

oldies have almost certainly reached their ceiling where as the young guns could go up a notch, bcos of that id lean to the new school

Dudge · November 27, 2011, 02:32:18 PM

Swan just over Pendles
Judd-Murphy 50/50
Ablett just over Jelwood
Boyd-ROCKY 50/50
Priddis over Swallow
NDS over Mundy

So i think oldies 4 with 2 draws. Mind u, it's a question that really makes u think, because i did change my mind a couple of times

Bluesman · November 27, 2011, 03:45:41 PM

Quote from: charliesheen on November 26, 2011, 04:14:16 PM
Who would come out on top?

S.Pendlebury, M.Murphy, J.Selwood, Rockliff, A.Swallow, D.Mundy

vs

D.Swan, C.Judd, G.Ablett, M.Boyd, M.Priddis, NDS

Impossible to really call but, in order i would generally go:
1. Ablett
2. Swan
3. Pendlebury
4. Selwood
5. Judd
6. Boyd
7. Murphy
8. Priddis
9. NDS
10. Mundy
11. Rockliff
12. Swallow

So based on this, adding their positions, i would have to say the Oldies have it - with 31 vs 47 (lowest total wins)

coolfugitiv0 · November 27, 2011, 04:19:10 PM

Swan > Pendles.
Judd and Murphy roughly even. Judd can star, but I think Murphy's more consistent.
Ablett > Selwood
Boyd < Rockliff
Priddis > Swallow
NDS > Mundy

Oldies for me. It will be interesting to look back at this thread at the end of the season and see if everyone still has the same opinions.

Ringo · November 27, 2011, 07:55:59 PM

Like this post. At the moment would give it to the oldies but there is a lot more upside to the young ones and would be interesting to revisit at season end.
Swan and Pendles even (too close to call)
Murphy over Judd (mainly because of Murph was more consistent this year)
Ablett over Selwood
Boyd and Rockliff even too close to call
Priddis over Swallow (Priddis more consistent)
NDS over Mundy
3 Oldies
1 Young Ones
2 even

My Chumps · December 03, 2011, 01:31:18 AM

This is the supercoach board, isn't it?
How are some of you rating Swan over Pendlebury?