Which Young Ruckmen?

Started by Purple 77, November 13, 2011, 02:33:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which young ruckmen?

Ayce Cordy
Max Gawn
Daniel Gorringe
Rhys Stanley

Purple 77

Who do you think would get more opportunities and/or who would score more?
Please don't tell me any other options, I would like to know out of these players:

Please note, this isn't necessarily just for next year, this is mainly in 3 or 4 years time

Thoughts?

Purple 77

Da! I might as well admit it, this is for a comp called the World 15's and I'm picking a player, I need a secondary ruckman for the long term and those are the best young ones available  ;D

Ziplock


elephants


nas

Stanley as also gives you at this current stage MPP > R/F

Chopps

i'd say Stanley at this stage

Torpedo10

I think Gorringe has the most upside.

Purple 77

Reasons for both stanley and gorringe?

Torpedo10

Gorringe will share the ruck with Smith so he will get a decent amount of taps. He has very good hands so he should be able to kick two or three goals each game.

Purple 77

Interesting.......... Gorringe sounds quite appealing

do you guys think stanley is more of a ruck or forward? If i were to pick him, i dont want him to be classified as a forward later on

CrowsFan

Trying to get some outside opinions huh P? :P

Purple 77

Quote from: CrowsFan on November 13, 2011, 06:14:50 PM
Trying to get some outside opinions huh P? :P

DAM! You found me! I posted in dreamteam coz the comp is on supercoach!

Well yeah.... lol

Any ideas?

Holz

Quote from: Purple 77 on November 13, 2011, 06:17:18 PM
Quote from: CrowsFan on November 13, 2011, 06:14:50 PM
Trying to get some outside opinions huh P? :P

DAM! You found me! I posted in dreamteam coz the comp is on supercoach!

Well yeah.... lol

Any ideas?



If i had to pick up another young ruck out of the list  i would get gorringe. Im looking at a couple of middle aged Rucks who could be good.

Pity you have a late pick in the draft Longer could be a great pick.


Purple 77

#13
Quote from: Holzman on November 13, 2011, 06:43:35 PM
Quote from: Purple 77 on November 13, 2011, 06:17:18 PM
Quote from: CrowsFan on November 13, 2011, 06:14:50 PM
Trying to get some outside opinions huh P? :P

DAM! You found me! I posted in dreamteam coz the comp is on supercoach!

Well yeah.... lol

Any ideas?

Oh ok, he must be the top ruck prospect????



If i had to pick up another young ruck out of the list  i would get gorringe. Im looking at a couple of middle aged Rucks who could be good.

Pity you have a late pick in the draft Longer could be a great pick.


Oh ok

Voldemort

Are these the only options? Gorringe will eventually come good so him I say