Main Menu

S15: FF U19 Squad - 5th Bowler Poll

Started by CrowsFan, November 01, 2011, 06:07:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

CrowsFan

Ok so we need to vote for the medium bowler for the nat team. The winner goes in to the squad and the runner up goes in to a second poll with the runner up from the other seamer poll :)

EDIT:
The poll has now been changed to decide who will be the fifth bowler in the squad. The three options all came second in their own polls and so only one of them goes through to the squad. When voting don't just vote on which is best, but also which would be best for the team by considering what bowlers are already in the squad. So far the squad consists of 2 FINGER SPINNERS, 1 MEDIUM, and 1 FAST MEDIUM.

Master Q

Didn't wanna vote for my two guys but both are the best atm...

CrowsFan

Sheikh makes the squad easily, with Jirongo following close behind. Jirongo has the second chance though

CrowsFan

The poll has now been changed so you can vote for who will get the final bowling spot. So vote away :)
To me it is pretty clear who should make it ;)

8-6 Suited


CrowsFan

Yeah I reckon a few will think that, but I reckon 3 spinners in the one team is too many. Also Jirongo is also a cap/cap bowler with ord batting so not much difference in their skills at all.

8-6 Suited

I thought there was only Slwana that went through?

8-6 Suited

Quote from: CrowsFan on November 02, 2011, 05:49:19 PM
Also Jirongo is also a cap/cap bowler with ord batting so not much difference in their skills at all.

Smart has a better summary in the same form, better experience at the same age and better fielding. Clear decision IMO for Smart over Jirongo.

CrowsFan

Quote from: 8-6 Suited on November 02, 2011, 05:53:28 PM
I thought there was only Slwana that went through?
Well the AR was also a spinner.
Why on earth did someone vote for Beattie? He doesn't deserve to be in the squad!

cookie311993

Need more strike power so I picked beattie.  Not best but adds strike power.  Beats smart as to me three spinners is to much

8-6 Suited

Your comment makes no sense cookie, as Smart is a WS and they not only can play on every possible pitch except maybe Green, but they are strike bowlers.

cookie311993

Last sentence I said to me 3 spinners is to much

8-6 Suited

No, he is terrible. I'd take Smart over him any day of the week. But looks like the people are voting the best player which is how it should go in my opinion.

Justin Bieber

I voted for Safi Jirongo as don't vote for my own players. Could have voted for Beattie as well, but don't think Rea/Rea should make the cut, sorry CF ;).

CrowsFan

Quote from: Hellopplz on November 03, 2011, 03:51:03 PM
I voted for Safi Jirongo as don't vote for my own players. Could have voted for Beattie as well, but don't think Rea/Rea should make the cut, sorry CF ;).
Haha neither do I. He is a fasty though, I reckon I will keep him in my senior squad cos he should be rel/rel by the time he is 20 and since they are rare I can train him up to something good...