S15: FF U19 Squad - Spinner Poll

[CrowsFan]

Only need the one spinner since the Kenneth Williamson our all rounder is also a spinner, so vote away :)

[Justin Bieber]

Dyer for me as I don't vote my own players.

By the way, what happens if the Seamers are of less quality than the Spinners? Couldn't we have say 3 Spinners (AR included) and 2 Seamers if so? Just a suggestion ;).

[CrowsFan]

We will see HP ;)

[Barlow 21]

Barry Smart over Dyer IMO as he has better secondaries and similar skills.

[PowerBug]

I had to vote Smart. Thought about gun, but had to vote smart.

[CrowsFan]

Hmm 6-3 is looking pretty convincing. Will leave the poll up till tomorrow but will start taking nominations for seamers :)

[8-6 Suited]

Why didnt this open for nominations for longer CF?

http://www.fromthepavilion.org/player.htm?playerId=626013


I would have nominated him.

[CrowsFan]

Nominations had been open for over 24 hours before I put up the poll. You had been on during that time so had an opportunity to nominate him. I will put him up now though ;)

[CrowsFan]

Tell you what, since he is actually rather good I have re set the poll, but in the future make sure you nominate in time ;)

[8-6 Suited]

It's a weekend CF, when I have been on, I have been drunk. And nominating isn't high on my priorities. In-fact, I am drunk right now and I didn't notice it until you actually set up the thread. I was out all of yesterday from 2pm onwards basically and today from 12pm.

just in future, not everyone is online on the weekends mate in a sober state lol

[8-6 Suited]

Wow, that came across rather harshly. I didn't mean it that way, I was just heavily intoxicated haha :P

[CrowsFan]

Nah all good shaggy, don't worry about it ;)

Well it seems that everyone who voted for Smart earlier has stuck with that vote, but the others all jumped camp from Dyer to Slwana haha. Will leave this open till I start the seamers poll tomorrow :)

[8-6 Suited]

Both Slwana and Dyer are similar in terms of most skills, just the 1 extra fielding and 3 extra levels of Endo make Slwana better. Smart is a nice WS though.

[cookie311993]

Yeah that was my thinking on the two shaggy and Smart would be the first one picked if HP recruited him as a 16yo

[Justin Bieber]

Thanks Guys. Shame Smart wasn't a 16 y.o, but I've never had a Wristy before (First ever in my squad) so planning on keeping him :). I don't mind Rel/Rel at 20 as long as secondaries are there 8).