My Top 50 of 2011

[bomberboy0618]

Mate i've watched roughy since he was 14. He is very valuable, but comparing him to Buddy is a farce  :-X
Rough was out for half the year and hawks still got to the Semi's, just missing out on granny.

Saying that without buddy Hawthorn wouldnt be top 8 is flowered. That just makes me mad.
When Roughy had his best year they won the granny, just saying. Dont underestimate him.

Got to agree with the first sentence.

Once again:

Are we hitting people? Cool!

[Master Q]

[Maca24]

Mate i've watched roughy since he was 14. He is very valuable, but comparing him to Buddy is a farce  :-X
Rough was out for half the year and hawks still got to the Semi's, just missing out on granny.

Saying that without buddy Hawthorn wouldnt be top 8 is flowered. That just makes me mad.
When Roughy had his best year they won the granny, just saying. Dont underestimate him.

I never said that, PB did?

[bomberboy0618]

I know. I just think that saying that hawks are fine with roughy is silly.

[Maca24]

I know. I just think that saying that hawks are fine with roughy is silly.

well their not. Just buddy is more valuable.

[bomberboy0618]

I know. I just think that saying that hawks are fine with roughy is silly.

well their not. Just buddy is more valuable.

I know. But when Roughy was at his best, Buddy kicked a ton. Roughy helps Buddy out a lot.

[My Chumps]

Zaharkis over Griffin?  :o

[Maca24]

Zaharkis over Griffin?  :o

Yep i'm biased  :P

[My Chumps]

Fair enough  :P
Reasons for Boyd to be that far off?

[BoredSaint]

JPK continues to be underrated.. :o

[truBLUE]

no andrew swallow  :o

[Ringo]

Fair Effort Macca as with any list open to conjecture.
Will not comment on Buddy at 1 as that has been covered previously.
Do not think Judd deserves to be No 4 given that he has not had his best season would rate Murphy above him this year.
Goodes should be definitely rated higher than 10, Goddard I would rate higher also and would have have Andrew Swallow in top 50 before Jack Riewoldt. Note you also have the Brownlow medalist Swan at 12 maybe he should be 6 or 7.
Just my thoughts.

[Maca24]

Thanks for the opinions guys.
Yes I was harsh on Swallow and JPK.
Swan I don't rate as top 10. Just a stat king.
Jack Riewoldt kicked a lot of goals this year even though it wasn't his best year.

[AFEV]

In my opinion, all the honourable mentions had better seasons than Zaha >_<

I think Cloke had a better year than SJ, and if we're going by importance/influence on the team, he'd be top 3 IMHO.

[ossie85]

I like your list Maca! Not much comment. Buddy was my #1 also