James Sellar

[Fyfe_gun]

Port need to make a play for him in trade week. CAPITAL N E E D.
He was a first round draft pick and is only like 23 and just what they need. Can play forward, defence and ruck and will get game time equaling development at port. Offload kane cornes for him and a draft pick or something I don't care just get him

[PowerBug]

No thanks.

Butcher >> Essendon
ESS top pick >> North Melbourne
McIntosh >> Port Adelaide

Sound fair?

[nas]

No thanks.

Butcher >> Essendon
ESS top pick >> North Melbourne
McIntosh >> Port Adelaide

Sound fair?

Nope.
Butcher > Essendon > Ryder & 2nd pick.
Butcher > Norths > HMac & 2nd Pick
Motlop > Freo > Griffen. keep Butcher

[valkorum]

No thanks.

Butcher >> Essendon
ESS top pick >> North Melbourne
McIntosh >> Port Adelaide

Sound fair?

Nope.
Butcher > Essendon > Ryder & 2nd pick.
Butcher > Norths > HMac & 2nd Pick
Motlop > Freo > Griffen. keep Butcher

Pfft - we dont want Motlop.  Surjan and you have me interested (only if we trade and get Mitch Clark)

[nas]

No thanks.

Butcher >> Essendon
ESS top pick >> North Melbourne
McIntosh >> Port Adelaide

Sound fair?

Nope.
Butcher > Essendon > Ryder & 2nd pick.
Butcher > Norths > HMac & 2nd Pick
Motlop > Freo > Griffen. keep Butcher

Pfft - we dont want Motlop.  Surjan and you have me interested (only if we trade and get Mitch Clark)

Better than Chris Groom.

[Wes Mantooth]

No thanks.

Butcher >> Essendon
ESS top pick >> North Melbourne
McIntosh >> Port Adelaide

Sound fair?

Powerbug - I am glad you are not our coach.

McIntosh has signed for Roos. I wouldnt want him anyway.
Butcher is going to resign. and Motlop looks good running off half back.
I think we need griffin to bolster the ruck stocks incase Lobbe gets injured.

[Fletch74]

No thanks.

Butcher >> Essendon
ESS top pick >> North Melbourne
McIntosh >> Port Adelaide

Sound fair?

Nope.
Butcher > Essendon > Ryder & 2nd pick.
Butcher > Norths > HMac & 2nd Pick
Motlop > Freo > Griffen. keep Butcher

I doubt if Butcher is worth that much as well. Ryder and 2nd pick for a player who's played a handful of games...

[nas]

No thanks.

Butcher >> Essendon
ESS top pick >> North Melbourne
McIntosh >> Port Adelaide

Sound fair?

Powerbug - I am glad you are not our coach.

McIntosh has signed for Roos. I wouldnt want him anyway.
Butcher is going to resign. and Motlop looks good running off half back.
I think we need griffin to bolster the ruck stocks incase Lobbe gets injured.

To add to that > No one plays the game with decent TRADES for Butcher into the draft he goes > GWS or to GWS for one of their 17 year old draft concessions. Full Stop

[valkorum]

No thanks.

Butcher >> Essendon
ESS top pick >> North Melbourne
McIntosh >> Port Adelaide

Sound fair?

Nope.
Butcher > Essendon > Ryder & 2nd pick.
Butcher > Norths > HMac & 2nd Pick
Motlop > Freo > Griffen. keep Butcher

Pfft - we dont want Motlop.  Surjan and you have me interested (only if we trade and get Mitch Clark)

Better than Chris Groom.

Thats debatable :P

[PowerBug]

No thanks.

Butcher >> Essendon
ESS top pick >> North Melbourne
McIntosh >> Port Adelaide

Sound fair?

Powerbug - I am glad you are not our coach.

Your saying that McIntosh wouldn't be a good pick up?

[nas]

No thanks.

Butcher >> Essendon
ESS top pick >> North Melbourne
McIntosh >> Port Adelaide

Sound fair?

Powerbug - I am glad you are not our coach.

Your saying that McIntosh wouldn't be a good pick up?

For what you are suggesting to get him Yes

[Wes Mantooth]

No thanks.

Butcher >> Essendon
ESS top pick >> North Melbourne
McIntosh >> Port Adelaide

Sound fair?

Powerbug - I am glad you are not our coach.

Your saying that McIntosh wouldn't be a good pick up?

At 27, 28 next year, why would we pick him up besides not being able to?
Far more value in younger players around. Griffin is 25...

[Fyfe_gun]

They don't need a great ruckman they just need someone to play beside lobbe because lobbe just needs some experience and he will be one of the best in league. He cant run out a full game yet and they dont have any other real ruckman so a sellar, zac clarke, mark blake would be perfect to back him up and play foward. In a rebuilding stage they should concentrate on building lobbe for the future rather than kicking him out of the team for a 28 or 29 year old.

They could do a motlop or surjan or even salopek straight swap for sellar i reckon..
geelong and freo might ask for a bit more though??

[PowerBug]

They don't need a great ruckman they just need someone to play beside lobbe because lobbe just needs some experience and he will be one of the best in league. He cant run out a full game yet and they dont have any other real ruckman so a sellar, zac clarke, mark blake would be perfect to back him up and play foward. In a rebuilding stage they should concentrate on building lobbe for the future rather than kicking him out of the team for a 28 or 29 year old.

They could do a motlop or surjan or even salopek straight swap for sellar i reckon..
geelong and freo might ask for a bit more though??

I'm sure we can lure a better ruckman than James Sellar. I don't rate him very highly, maybe others do, not sure.

[nas]

Plain n simple >> Griffen. Wants to return to SA

.http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl/former-crow-ports-next-target/story-e6freco3-1226132682271