Broughton V Puopolo

[Bak2Form]

grandfinal decision or i have $78,800 in the bank to trade broughton but seems a waste as i have most the best backs already and just fall short of scotland

Goddard,Deledio,Birchall,Gibbs,Enright, Suckling, Broughton
(poo,howard,jacobs)

[HevvieEvvie]

Broughton is poo get in Bock

[hardnut]

I'm in similar boat, if Broughton plays (and he may not) then I'd just stick it out. He actually has a very good average against the Dogs and wouldn't you hate to trade him and he gets thrown in the guts for a 100+ costing you your GF.

I suspect there will plenty of selection headaches this week to keep us all busy.

[dale93]

Dont get rid of Broughts because of the Freo Injurys he is Guanerteed Midfield time all game which means a ton :)

[plugz19]

Dont get rid of Broughts because of the Freo Injurys he is Guanerteed Midfield time all game which means a ton :)

last week he should have got mid time to and didnt..

[woofy]

Dont get rid of Broughts because of the Freo Injurys he is Guanerteed Midfield time all game which means a ton :)

last week he should have got mid time to and didnt..

maybe he was still abit sore in the ribs and couldn't play in that position? I saw fyfe alot in the mids and since his not playing broughton might be the one.

[Possumo]

Broughton is too much of a risk to play I'd reckon... even if he does ton up, getting another premium that is more likely too score high is the better option I reckon... although he played poorly last week, Fisher may still be a good option... Carazzo or Bock too might be worth a look? This is assuming there is no other important trade you could make that could help you out more this week... as the Puo vs the suns would be more than likely to score 80+ like 90% of the Hawks...

[LEV]

tough call, broughton should get a run in the midfield, whilst poo is playing gold coast.  tough tough tough. His 129 last week got me through the the GF by 15 points  :) :) :) :) :) :)

[PowerBug]

Broughton, he's the premium, you play him.

[Grazz]

Broughton, he's the premium, you play him.

Have to agree 100% play the premium.

[Windigo]

Don't chase last weeks points by playing Pou.

I'd pick Broughton, even though he ain't going that great....

[bigsy]

i don't know, puops could smash it, if you look at the stats small forwards have been known to rip it against the suns, and puops has been spending time up forwards....

[Grazz]

Poo only mannaged a 68 last time they played with the Hawks dominating. Broughton didnt play against the Dogs in rnd 5
so its hard to gauge how he may go this week. With Lower and Mundy plus a host of others missing this week i think Broughton
is a big chance to go in the middle and we all know what that means for him. With that in mind and a prem over a rookie ive gotta be honest its still Broughton for me. Ya gotta risk it to get the biscuit!!.

[bundyboy]

let's not all get carried away with Poo's last game....yeh, he was super good, but look at the weeks before - only average..

yes Broughton a dissappointment again after starring for a little during middle of the season..but still more likely to punch out a winning score than Puopolo - imo anyway..that's where I would be going..

[Windigo]

I think people are voting for Puo purely because he is playing GC.....