Is stevieJ 35k better than davis???

Started by Jay, August 26, 2011, 06:29:43 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who should come in???

StevieJ (35k more expensive)
9 (60%)
Davis (35k cheaper)
6 (40%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Jay

im trading pav to one of SJ and NEON LEON DAVIS

Thinking stevieJ just edges davis but there wont be much between them so should the $ $ $ make a difference???

It would use up basically all my cap if i went stevieJ which wouldnt be perfect because i will more than likely be playing in the gf next week and will have to trade then. So im really actually focusing on who should score more next week.

STEVIEJ PROS
has sydney and collingwood (he scored 127 vs sydney & 130 v collingwood last time played)
STEVIEJ NEG
More expensive

DAVIS PROS
He can play back and fwd so when he isnt scoring in backs he can go forward and still score well
Should enjoy the wide-open spaces at subi this week
DAVIS NEG
He might cop a tag next week when playing geelong...if he doesnt get rested that is
A finals like game coming up next week and leon has a history of not performing.

Really undecided still so please help :)

nathan11

stevie J would not bring in someone who sat out last week

charliesheen


roo boys!

I'd say get Stevie J.

I am wondering if Stevie J is much better than Goodes? :-\

Slammer

Steve J sat out last week aswell..lol.

Go Neon. has been rested.

As you said Neon could cop a tag. Thats why he will then go forward to break tag.
Neon for me. SJ can be really good or really crap.
Reckon Neon will be more consistent.

goodes37

stevie j only because he scores well at skilled stadium and he scored 130 against collingwood last time they played

charliesheen

just go with your gut, your better off backing your own judgement and making your own mistakes.

analyze the data, make a decision, and march to your own beat.

Jay

Yeh good post CS

Think ill go stevieJ...anyone think adding fyfe to the options will change anythin???

nathan11

Quote from: Jayman on August 26, 2011, 06:55:49 PM
Yeh good post CS

Think ill go stevieJ...anyone think adding fyfe to the options will change anythin???

yes stevie j isn't 75 000 better than fyfe if you are worried about the coin

roo boys!

I think I might pick Fyfe then, because more money to trade out Hepp next week.

Jay

Yeh thats a good point. I dont know hahaha!

If i get stevieJ i will have no cash to work with next week BUT i do think stevie should score more than fyfe. Its hard finding that balance between $$$ and points

Keep opinions coming please

Jay

FYI im also trading broughton this week and was thinking bock BUT i could go suckling instead then i would be able to go stevieJ and still have $ $ $ in bank???

roo boys!

Who will you be trading out next week?

Jay


charliesheen

are you still spinning your head on this lol.

easy decision imo.

unless you got like $1000 on the line or something loll